By the fourth day, the water began to fall. On the last morning of January the causeway emerged again, brown and slippery and strewn with reeds, just in time for the sale. All morning people arrived in coaches, carts, and on horseback, their boots muddy to the knee. There were dealers from Bath and Bristol in fine coats, farmers hoping to purchase land, and ladies eager to see the furnishings of a house to which they had never been invited.

The great hall had been scrubbed, though it still smelled faintly of river water. Chairs stood in rows upon the damp stone floor. At the far end the man from Bridgewater sat at a table with his long inventory and little ivory hammer. Lady Celeste occupied a front-row seat in her blue velvet gown, back very straight, looking at nobody.

The duke was nowhere to be seen.

Susanna had glimpsed him from her window at dawn, walking alone down the causeway toward the gate and the church across the moor, where his godmother lay buried. He had not said where he was going or what he meant to do when the sale began. Since the night with the book, he had hardly spoken. Susanna had not asked. She had no right to ask.

Now she sat at the back of the hall beside Silas in her faded blue dress, hands folded in her lap. She watched the door and told herself it did not matter whether Nicholas came. That was untrue, and she knew it.

At ten precisely, the man from Bridgewater rose, read the duke’s written instructions in a dry voice, and began. He started with the paintings because the dealers had come especially for them.

The first restored picture stood on an easel beside his table: the Summer Meadow. It caught the pale light from the high windows, and the room grew still. It was nothing like the brown object that had hung beside the gallery door for a hundred years. Cattle stood among the buttercups, the church tower rose in the distance, and the vast sky stretched clear and blue, filled with light and high white clouds moving toward the sea.

A dealer from Bath lifted his spectacles and leaned forward. Lady Celeste stood.

“Before anybody makes a bid,” she announced pleasantly, “I think the room ought to know the truth. You have been told these pictures were cleaned by Silas, formerly one of London’s finest restorers. They were not. Everyone in the parish knows his hands have shaken for years. The pictures were scrubbed by his girl, a laundress’s daughter, with a bottle of spirits and no proper training beyond what she picked up carrying his things. If any gentleman here wishes to buy a picture…”

“…that’s had half its paint scrubbed away, he is welcome to it.”

Celeste smiled and sat down.

“I thought it only fair to mention it.”

A murmur ran through the hall like wind through reeds. The dealer from Bath dropped his spectacles. Two men in the second row leaned their heads together. Susanna felt the faces in the room turning toward the back, one after another. Beside her, Silas went rigid.

She ought to remain seated. That was safest, and she knew it. If she stayed quiet, the pictures would sell for less. Silas’s reputation would suffer a little. Within a week the parish would find something else to talk about. If she stood up, however, there would be nowhere left to hide. Every gentleman in the county would know that the master’s finest work had been done by a girl, and half of them would never send another picture to the workshop. The woman who had made the accusation might well own that workshop by nightfall.

Susanna stood.

“Lady Celeste is right about one thing,” she said.

Her voice carried farther than she expected in the high, cold hall.

“I cleaned them. Every painting in this sale, and every painting finished by Silas’s workshop in the last four winters. He taught me everything I know from the time I was twelve. But the hand holding the swab was mine. If any gentleman here thinks the sky has been damaged, he is welcome to inspect it closely. I shall stand beside him while he does.”