She opened her eyes.

Bishop stood upon her, all four paws planted firmly, staring into her face from inches away with his dull gold gaze. She held her breath. Slowly, in the deliberate way of cats, he turned once in a circle and kneaded her apron with his great paws, claws pressing in and then withdrawing. He settled against her chest, tucked his torn ear beneath her chin, and began to purr. It was a deep, rough, rusty sound, like a carriage rumbling over a wooden bridge very far away.

Susanna did not move. Very carefully, as though she held a fragile painting, she put her arms around him. He was heavier than she expected, and warmer. Within a minute his eyes had closed. Within two, he was fast asleep.

That was how the duke found them.

He stopped in the doorway. She saw his expression change. He came slowly down the long room and stood looking at the sleeping cat in her arms. For a long time he said nothing. When he spoke, his voice was low, almost as though they were in church.

“That cat has never let anyone touch him,” he said. He paused. “Except my godmother.”

“I didn’t ask him to,” Susanna whispered. “He decided.”

Nicholas sat down on the floor on the other side of the hearth, his back against the wall and his long legs drawn up, in an attitude wholly unbecoming a duke. The fire lay between them, and the cat slept. Neither wished to wake him, so they talked in whispers. Whispering seemed to make talking easier.

Nicholas told her that his godmother had found Bishop in a ditch during a flood seven or eight years earlier, almost drowned. He had bitten her to the bone, yet she had carried him home in her shawl. She called him Bishop because he sat in her window like a bishop at prayer. He slept on her bed every night and occupied her windowsill every day. When she died, he refused to leave the chair for a week.

“I know,” the duke said. “She wrote to me about that cat every Christmas. Pages about the cat.”

He stared into the fire.

“Not one word asking me to come.”

Susanna did not answer. She did not know how. She held the warm cat and watched the duke’s face in the firelight. She thought she had never seen anyone look so tired and so lonely while sitting in a room with another person.

Bishop slept nearly an hour. When he woke at last, he stretched, yawned in Susanna’s face, and returned to his window as though nothing unusual had happened. Susanna rose stiffly and went back to her table. Her fingers were warm now.

She picked up her cotton. Instead of leaving, the duke came and stood beside her to watch. She was cleaning the summer meadow. She had left the sky until last because skies were the hardest part. A sky revealed every mistake. She worked in small, even strokes, and the brown disappeared to reveal a great pale-blue space full of light, with high white clouds moving toward the sea.

She did not hurry. Her hand did not shake. When she glanced up, he was not looking at the painting. He was looking at her hands.

“Silas says he hasn’t touched these,” he said.

It was not a question. Susanna set down the swab. She considered lying and found that she did not want to, especially not to him.

“No,” she said.

“Not for four winters. His hands tremble. Everybody in the village knows, though nobody will say it. The gentlemen who send us pictures think he does the work because his name is on the papers and because he was once the best in London. If they knew it was me, they wouldn’t send them. Nobody trusts a girl with a picture worth a hundred guineas.”

“You are better than London’s best.”

“I was taught by London’s best. That isn’t the same thing.”

Their eyes met.

“Your Grace, please don’t tell anyone. His reputation keeps the work coming. Without it there would be no workshop. Without the workshop, he would have nothing.”

Nicholas was silent for a long time.