“It is a lie,” he said at last.
“It is a kindness. Those aren’t the same thing either.”
The corner of his mouth moved. It was not quite a smile.
“Very well. I shall keep your secret on one condition.”
He nodded toward the summer meadow.
“When you finish, tell me exactly where it was painted. I think I know. I want to be sure.”
That evening, because the cold was so bitter and darkness came so early, he walked her home. She told him it was unnecessary. He said it was very necessary indeed and took the lantern out of her hand. That settled the matter.
They went through the garden door and down the frozen causeway between the willows, the lantern swinging and ice cracking softly in the ditches beside them. The moor spread away, black and white beneath a thin moon. They spoke very little. Once he stopped to look back at Southwood rising above the moor, a light in the library and another in the gallery. Susanna heard him counting under his breath.
When they reached the little bridge, he said, “Nine.”
She understood that he had been counting the willows.
“She taught me that,” Susanna said. “Eleven to the bridge and nine to the gate, so I would never lose my way on the causeway at night.”
He looked at her strangely in the lantern light.
“She taught me the same thing,” he said, “when I was fifteen.”
The cottage stood at the far end of the village, where the road gave out. Frost whitened the thatch and a lamp glowed in the workshop window. Silas opened the door himself. He looked at the duke, then at Susanna, and then back at the duke. He did not bow. He had never bowed to anyone in his life and was too old to begin.
“You’d best come in and get warm,” he said. “You won’t find a servant here, so you’ll have to take your own coat off.”
The duke removed his coat. He sat beside the workshop stove, among the easels, bottles, and smell of turpentine, and drank a cup of Silas’s terrible tea without complaint.
Susanna watched him look about the room. He took in the paintings waiting on the racks, Silas’s hands wrapped round his cup, and the finished little river picture with its white sail drying by the window. Then his glance went to the open door of the back room, where small pictures stood stacked against the wall. Susanna’s own work: herons on ice, church spires in fog, her ladyship dozing on the windowsill with the cat across her knees.
“Who painted those?” he asked.
“Nobody,” Susanna said, and went to close the door.
Silas, who had never possessed much tact and had no desire to acquire any, put down his cup.
“You know this cottage belongs to Southwood, Your Grace. I’ll speak plainly, because Susanna won’t. If Lady Celeste buys the place, we’ll have to leave before spring. She’s said so in front of half the parish. I’m too old to care where I die, but this girl has nowhere else in the world.”
He looked at the duke beneath his white eyebrows.
“Your godmother knew that. She used to say you and Susanna would suit each other. Told me so more than once. I think you ought to know, seeing as she can’t tell you herself.”
“Silas,” Susanna said, scandalised.
But the duke only looked into his cup.
“She said a great many things,” he answered quietly, “to everyone but me.”
He walked back alone. He refused the lantern.
He said he knew the way. He went along the moonlit causeway counting the willows. At the little bridge he stopped for a long time with his hands on the cold railing, looking across the ice at Southwood’s dark shape and its two lighted windows. He had come to sell a house. He had not expected the house to look back at him.
“Nine to the gate,” he thought. She had taught both of them the same way home.
On Sunday the whole village came out upon the ice. This happened every few winters on the Levels, when floodwater froze hard enough to bear a horse. The drowned fields became a vast white plain stretching for miles between the willows. Anyone with skates, anyone who could borrow a pair, or anyone who could tie two pieces of cattle bone to their boots came skating after church. Boys raced from one distant church tower to another. Old men stood wrapped in scarves, declaring that this winter was nothing compared with the winters of their youth. Somebody always roasted chestnuts over a brazier at the edge. And there was always a dog that barked after the skaters and slid across the ice on its belly to thunderous applause.