He did not flinch. Then she set her foot in a groom’s cupped hands, swung up and sat. A sound ran around the paddock, not quite a cheer, not quite a gasp. A baronet dropped his quizzing glass.
Lady Whitby clutched her husband’s arm. Harriet touched her heel to Mercury’s side and the great black horse walked. She asked for more and he trotted easy and even, his head carried high and his ears pricked. Once around the full circuit of the paddock, she brought him back to the fence and halted him in front of the Duke.
Nobody laughed.
The Duke walked into the middle of the paddock and turned to face the crowd. He was pale, but his voice carried to the last carriage.
“Three years ago at the Salisbury Assembly, a lady was insulted before 200 of you. Her only offense was understanding horses better than gentlemen. I stood in the doorway and said nothing, and many of you laughed. I did not, but that is no credit to me. Silence is a kind of laughter, and I have been ashamed of mine ever since.”
He turned.
“Miss Penrose, I beg your pardon.”
The paddock held perfectly still.
“My father died on the 9th of October, 1815. You were told the horse killed him. That was a lie, and I let it stand because I could not bear the truth.”
He nodded to Harriet.
“Show them.”
She slid from the saddle and laid something in her open palm.
“This was lodged in Mercury’s withers for 18 months. A saddler’s nail driven through the pad of the old Duke’s saddle.”
The nail caught the sun. A gasp passed through the crowd like wind through barley.
“And this,” the Duke continued, lifting the severed strap, “was found in the tack room by my head groom, Thomas Whitlock, on the 8th of October. He tried to warn me. He was dismissed within the month on a false charge and died in poverty the following February.”
Near the kitchen door, Mrs. Whitlock stood small and upright in her black dress, weeping without a sound. She did not look away.
“I have a witness,” said the Duke. “My sister.”
Cecily stepped out beside him. Her knees shook and her hands were knotted so tightly her knuckles shone white, but she lifted her chin.
“At dawn on the 9th of October, 1815, I saw my cousin, Lord Percival Garrow, leave the tack room carrying a candle. His right hand was wrapped in a bloodied handkerchief.”
Her voice began as a thread and strengthened with every word.
“He told me I had dreamed it. I did not dream it. I was afraid and I was 17. I am 19 now.”
“Absurd,” Garrow drawled, though his smile had gone stiff. “A hysterical girl and a servant’s widow. Any man might have cut his hand.”
“You wore a glove on that hand for 6 weeks,” Sir Hugh Alder remarked from the fence, frowning. “I remember it clearly. You told the whole county a dog had bitten you.”