“A horse is a horse,” Garrow retorted. “It has no sense of mercy.”

“No, but it has an excellent memory for hurt.”

She walked to the stall and stopped at the half door. Inside, the black stallion stood trembling in the shadows, his flanks dark with sweat, his eyes rolling white. The crowd leaned in, waiting for her to scream and run. Harriet held out one open palm and said nothing at all. The stallion’s breathing slowed, his head came down, and for the first time that morning, Mercury went quiet. The Duke had crossed the yard without a sound, and now stood close enough that she could feel him there.

“Miss Penrose,” he asked in a voice that was barely his own, “what do you see?”

She did not turn around.

“An animal that has suffered for a long time, Your Grace, and I do not think it is chance that no one in this yard has ever found out why.”

Across the cobbles, Garrow’s smile slipped. It lasted only an instant, and the crowd was watching the horse. But the old housekeeper at the kitchen door, her arms wrapped around a bread crock, was watching Garrow. Her knuckles had gone white.

The Duke let her stay, and that was the first surprise. Garrow argued for a quarter of an hour in the stable yard, his voice smooth and heavy. A woman could not be risked. The county would talk, and his late uncle’s memory demanded a clean end. The Duke heard him out to the last syllable and answered with six words that closed the subject.

“Miss Penrose has until the 1st of May.”

Garrow bowed, smiled with all his teeth, and withdrew. The crowd drifted after him, disappointed, until only the Duke remained at the fence, and Harriet, and the black horse breathing in the dark.

“What do you require?” he asked her.

“Nobody in the stable but me. No whips, no spurs, no bit. And you at the far fence, Your Grace, not the near one. He can smell fear on a man at 40 paces.”

“I am not afraid.”

“You have not blinked since I said his name.”

He studied her for a long moment. Then he walked to the far fence and stayed there.

Harriet sat down in the straw outside the stall and did nothing for 4 hours. She hummed an old Wiltshire reaping tune her father had used on mares frightened of thunder, low and tuneless, the way one hums when one is not really singing. The sun climbed, dust turned gold in the doorway, and by the third hour the stallion’s head had come down level with her shoulder. By the fourth, he allowed her palm to rest against his neck. Then she slid her hand up toward the withers and he screamed.

It was not temper. She had seen temper in horses all her life. This was the sound of an animal pressed with a hot iron. She snatched her hand back and sat motionless while he plunged against the wall, and when he finally stilled, she touched the ridge between his shoulders with the backs of her fingers. There was heat there and a swelling as hard as a fist beneath the mane and a faint sweet rot smell her father had taught her never to forget.