The stallion shuddered. The Duke murmured low and steady into his ear. A flood of dark matter poured into the bucket, foul and thick, and the stench filled the stable.

Then the lancet scraped something hard. Harriet went still. She reached in with the forceps and drew out an object the length of her finger. It rang against the bucket.

She lifted it into the lantern light, a rusted iron nail, square-cut, snapped off short with a scrap of green baize still fused to its head, and caught in the baize, stamped into a shred of leather, small but perfectly legible, R. Hollis, Sarum. The duke’s face drained of color.

“That is my father’s saddler. That is the pad from his saddle, the one he rode on the 9th. ” He stared as though at a snake. “It was driven through the pad, point down. When he mounted, it went into the horse, and when the horse threw him…”

He stopped.

“Percival had the saddle burned that same afternoon. ‘Out of respect,’ he said.”

“That is why Mercury screams whenever anything touches him,” Harriet answered quietly. “The shaft snapped off in the wound. He has carried it for 18 months.”

The duke’s hands began to shake so badly that the stallion shifted.

“We quarreled that morning. I refused to ride and my father took the horse in my place. I have believed for 18 months that I killed him.”

“Alexander.”

It was the first time she had used his name.

“You did not. A man with a nail did.”

He bowed his head against the horse’s neck. Harriet did not touch him. She simply stood holding the lantern until the worst had passed. When he straightened, his eyes were red but clear.

“I failed you at dinner,” he said. “I failed you in 1814. I will not fail you a third time.”

“Then say it where I was shamed,” she replied very low, “in front of the same people. That is the only apology I will accept.”

“I will say it before every soul who ever laughed at you on the 1st of May.”

“Then I will stay until the 1st of May,” Harriet answered, “and not a day longer.”

She still carried the bundle at first light, and she was halfway across the orchard when someone stepped out from the trees. Cecily wore her shawl over her nightgown, and her bare feet were wet with dew. In her hands lay a long, stiff, brown-stained strip of leather.

“You are leaving,” she accused. “You told me you liked me. Was it true, or only kindness?”

“Both,” Harriet admitted, setting down the bundle. “I am staying as it happens.”

“Then stay for me, not for him.”

Cecily’s chin trembled.

“And take this.”

She held out the leather. It was a girth strap, severed along a line too clean for wear.

“Mrs. Whitlock gave it to me the day before yesterday. She kept it in the bread crock for 18 months. Her husband found it in the tack room the night before my father died, and went to tell the Duke, and Garrow caught him first. A month later, Thomas Whitlock was dismissed for stealing a snuffbox, and by February he was dead.”