CHAPTER 3

I locked our bedroom door, then turned the photograph over. It was a grainy image from a security camera, printed on ordinary office paper. The timestamp in the corner made my chest tighten.

Two nights earlier. 2:13 a.m. Andre was standing in our upstairs hallway.

He was wearing a dark baseball cap and the gray jacket he always kept in the back of his SUV. His face was tilted toward our bedroom door, and one hand held a small black folder against his side. I stared at the picture until the numbers blurred.

Reid and I had been away that night. We had driven to Durham for my cousin’s birthday dinner and stayed late enough that we didn’t get home until after midnight. I remembered coming into the house exhausted, kicking off my shoes, barely noticing anything except how badly I wanted sleep.

Andre had been inside our home before we got back. The back of the photograph had one sentence written in Reid’s careful handwriting.

“He didn’t come for me.”

I picked up the envelope with shaking hands. For a moment, I almost put it back down. I wanted to believe the photograph had an explanation. Maybe Andre had come by because of an emergency. Maybe Reid had asked him to check on something.

But then I remembered Andre’s text. Don’t open whatever Reid left. He knew.

I tore open the envelope. Inside was a folded note, a small brass key, and a second photograph. This one was clearer. It showed Andre sitting on the edge of my side of the bed, his head lowered as he looked through the drawer in my nightstand.

The drawer where I kept old birthday cards, tax paperwork, and a stack of letters my mother had written before she died. I sat down hard on the mattress. The note began with my name.

“Sienna, I’m not leaving this to punish you for today. What happened at the cookout hurt, but it also confirmed something I have been trying not to believe.”

My eyes moved across the page too fast at first, then slowed.

Reid wrote that he had noticed small things over the past few months. A drawer left slightly open. A necklace moved from its box. A private letter from my sister sitting in the wrong stack. At first, he thought he was imagining it.

Then, three weeks ago, he found the lockbox by the garage open. Only three people knew the code: Reid, me, and Andre. Reid had installed a camera facing the upstairs hallway without telling anyone. He said he hated doing it. He said he had hoped he would find nothing and feel foolish for ever suspecting his best friend.

Instead, he caught Andre entering our house five different times. Every time, I had been gone. My phone buzzed against my palm. Andre was calling.

I watched his name light up the screen until it stopped. A second later, a voicemail notification appeared. I did not play it.

Not yet. I kept reading. Reid wrote that Andre never took electronics, jewelry, or cash. He went through my things. My desk. The boxes in the closet. The nightstand beside the bed. Once, according to the camera footage, Andre stood in front of my vanity mirror for nearly ten minutes, holding one of my old college photos in his hand.

A cold, sick feeling spread through me. The photograph had been taken years before I met Reid. It showed me laughing outside a diner with friends, my hair shorter, my face younger. I had not seen it in months.