CHAPTER 4
Andre had. The note continued.
“Yesterday, I confronted him. He told me he was worried about you. He said you had been unhappy for a long time and that you confided in him because you were afraid to talk to me.”
I let out a short, disbelieving breath. I had never said that. I had complained about marriage sometimes, the way people do when they are tired or frustrated. I had told Andre that Reid worked too much. I had once admitted I felt invisible after a bad week.
But I had never told Andre I was afraid of my husband. I had never asked Andre to speak for me. Reid’s next line made my hands go numb.
“He showed me messages that appeared to come from you.”
I read it again. Then a third time.
Reid wrote that Andre had held up screenshots during their confrontation. Messages supposedly sent from me late at night. Messages saying I regretted marrying Reid. Messages saying I wished I had chosen someone who understood me better.
The words felt like they had been pulled from my deepest insecurities and sharpened into weapons. I knew I had never written them. But I also knew how easily Andre could have learned exactly what would sound believable.
My phone lit up again, this time with a message from Camille.
“Sienna, are you okay? Reid came by earlier. He asked me something strange.”
I called her immediately. Camille answered on the first ring.
“Where are you?”
“At home,”
I said.
“What did Reid ask you?”
There was a pause.
“He asked whether you had ever told me you were scared of him.”
My grip tightened around the phone.
“No. Never.”
“That’s what I told him.”
Her voice became quieter.
“Sienna, he looked wrecked. Not angry. Just… like he had been carrying something awful alone.”
I looked down at the brass key resting on the bedspread.
“What else did he say?”
Camille exhaled slowly.
“He said Andre had been putting words in your mouth. Then he told me not to answer Andre if he contacted me.”
At that exact moment, Andre’s voicemail began playing through my phone speaker. His voice was low, urgent, and nothing like the relaxed man from the cookout.
“Sienna, listen to me. Reid is not telling you the whole story. He found something he was never supposed to find. Please don’t use the key.”
The message ended. Camille heard it too. Neither of us spoke for several seconds.
Then I unfolded the bottom of Reid’s note. Beneath the final paragraph, he had written one more instruction.
“The key opens the metal box in the garage. I need you to see what Andre saved about you before he gets the chance to erase it.”
I looked toward the bedroom door. Then I heard a sound downstairs. Not a creak.
Not the house settling. The unmistakable click of our front door unlocking.
I did not move toward the bedroom door. The sound downstairs came again—slow footsteps across the hardwood, followed by the soft scrape of something being dragged near the garage entry. My first instinct was to hide the note, the photographs, and the brass key. Then I stopped myself.
Andre had spent months making me doubt my own instincts. I was done helping him control the evidence. I took pictures of every page Reid had left me. The hallway images. The note. The key. Andre’s warning text. Then I sent them all to Camille with one message:
“Save these. If anything happens, do not delete them.”
CHAPTER 5