CHAPTER 6
The drop to the lawn was not far, but my knees buckled when I landed. For one second, I stayed crouched in the dark grass, listening. From inside the garage came the sound of a drawer slamming shut.
I moved around the side of the house and reached the open garage door just enough to see inside. Andre was kneeling beside the metal box. The lid was open.
The contents had been tossed across the concrete floor—folders, printed screenshots, two small memory cards, and what looked like copies of my mother’s old letters. One of the letters had been ripped open. My stomach turned.
He had not just gone through my private things. He had copied them. Andre picked up one of the memory cards and held it between two fingers.
“You should’ve let this go,”
he muttered.
I raised my phone and started recording. He must have heard the faint movement because he looked over his shoulder. For the first time that night, his expression changed completely.
The charm disappeared.
“Sienna,”
he said. I stepped into the garage doorway, keeping space between us.
“Put it down.”
He looked at the phone in my hand, then back at me.
“You really think Reid is the person you should trust?”
“I think you broke into my home five times.”
“I came here because you were drowning and nobody else saw it.”
“You came here when I was gone.”
“You gave me reasons to believe you wanted out.”
“I gave you complaints,”
I said.
“You turned them into a story where you could save me.”
His jaw tightened.
I saw it then—the anger underneath every smooth smile, every compliment, every time he had acted like he understood me better than my husband did. He had not wanted to rescue me from Reid. He had wanted to become the only person whose version of me mattered.
Andre stood slowly.
“Reid will never forgive what happened at that cookout.”
“That was my mistake to face,”
I said.
“Not yours to use.”
A distant siren cut through the quiet street. Andre’s eyes flicked toward the open garage door. Then he looked down at the scattered papers, and his face changed again. Not fear exactly. Calculation.
He reached into his jacket pocket. I took one step back.
“Don’t,”
I said.
But he did not pull out a weapon. He pulled out his phone. A message appeared on my screen at the same time.
It was from Reid. My breath caught before I even opened it. There was only one line.
“Why is Andre telling me you asked him to take the box before the police arrived?”
I looked up at Andre. He had already sent something to Reid.
Something fast enough, convincing enough, to make my husband question me before I could explain. The sirens were getting closer. On the garage floor, beside Andre’s shoe, one of my mother’s copied letters had fallen open. A sentence near the bottom was circled in red ink.
I had never circled it. And beneath the circle, in handwriting I recognized from the envelope on my pillow, were four words that made my heart stop:
“Ask Sienna about June.”
The circled sentence came from one of my mother’s letters, written years before she died. I knew the page immediately because I had read it so many times after the funeral. But the red circle was new.
And so were the words beneath it.
“Ask Sienna about June.”
Andre saw me looking at it and stepped toward the paper.
“You don’t understand what that means.”