The clerk, Nina Patel, checked the computer twice. Isaiah’s application appeared in the correspondence log but not in the audition roster. “It says withdrawn,” she said. Isaiah shook his head. He had never withdrawn. Nina called the fellowship office, where an assistant insisted the registration deadline had passed. The next family in line demanded attention. Isaiah stood beside a planter, looking at the doors behind which the orchestra was tuning. If he left, his grandmother would tell him she was proud anyway. That thought was almost unbearable.

Nina returned carrying a paper envelope. Inside was a copy of Isaiah’s original application with the signature of the volunteer who had discovered him at the library. An unfamiliar correction had been written across the top: INELIGIBLE, NO REQUIRED PREPARATION. She noticed that the correction lacked a date and an authorized signature. “I’ll take this to someone who can decide,” she said. Isaiah watched her disappear through a staff corridor.

Inside the lobby, bright photographs of former scholarship winners lined the wall. Isaiah studied their polished instruments and formal jackets, then looked at his own reflection in the glass. He had never wanted a fine jacket so badly. It was foolish, he knew, to believe clothes could change his playing, yet he worried they had already changed how people heard him. He remembered his grandfather’s steady voice.

A boy in a tailored jacket approached, introduced himself as Andrew Mercer, and glanced at Isaiah’s case. He did not laugh. “People get nervous in there,” Andrew said. “They act worse than they are.” Isaiah wondered whether that was true. Andrew offered him a seat and a piece of peppermint candy. Before Isaiah could answer, Nina emerged with a visitor’s badge and said, “You’re being allowed to play, but Mr. Harlan wants to see you first.”

Harlan greeted Isaiah with a smile that never reached his eyes. He had already spoken to trustees, donors, and parents about the excellence of Bellweather’s training system. An applicant with no private teacher challenged that story. “We cannot create exceptions simply because a child has an interesting background,” he told Nina. She replied that the audition was supposed to judge musical ability. His gaze hardened at her interruption.

When Isaiah explained that his grandfather had taught him, Harlan asked for a conservatory credential. Isaiah could offer only the church where Samuel played and the library where he himself practiced. Harlan said the fellowship required discipline, not sentiment. Nina pointed to the published rules: applicants from twelve to sixteen were eligible, no private lessons were required, and financial circumstances could not disqualify them. Harlan closed the booklet without acknowledging the correction.

Harlan’s office held trophies behind glass and a framed photograph of a gala. He spoke smoothly about standards, using words that sounded reasonable until Isaiah tried to picture what they meant in practice. How could he demonstrate training he had never been allowed to purchase? How could the school discover unfamiliar talent if it listened only to those already known? Isaiah did not deliver a speech. He remembered his grandfather’s steady voice.

He finally agreed to let Isaiah enter after everyone on the printed roster. “You will have three minutes,” he said. “One selection. No special accommodation.” Isaiah nodded, though the scheduled excerpt required nearly four minutes at the proper tempo. As he waited outside, he heard a girl play the passage flawlessly. Then Andrew played it differently and drew appreciative murmurs. Isaiah closed his eyes, trying to hear the opening in Samuel’s voice. At that moment a custodian approached and whispered, “Your grandfather once warned me about this committee.”