Harlan reminded him of the three-minute limit. Leonard replied that the published excerpt should be played complete. They exchanged a look that made the room uncomfortable. Finally Harlan allowed Isaiah to begin, but only after pointing out that the ensemble had spent the morning accompanying trained applicants. Isaiah took out the violin, checked the bridge, and tightened his bow. His fingers trembled enough that he had to loosen his grip and start again.

The accompanist was a woman named Celia Price, who had taught beginners for years. She noticed Isaiah looking past her toward the exit and spoke to him in the same voice she used with anxious students. ‘I’ll follow you,’ she said. ‘You don’t have to chase me.’ Isaiah nodded. That small assurance helped him feel less alone, although the tall windows and solemn faces still seemed to weigh upon the room. The room seemed less certain now. He listened closely.

The first note was not magical. It was slightly thin, a little exposed, and honest. Isaiah stopped after the second measure because the violin had slipped on his shoulder. A judge wrote something quickly. Harlan folded his arms. Isaiah thought of the kitchen ceiling leaking into the soup pot. Leonard raised one hand. “Take your time,” he said. “Music doesn’t improve when we’re cruel to it.” Isaiah reset the instrument. Behind him, the pianist asked whether he would like the opening chord again.

Isaiah nodded to the pianist, and the room settled. The next opening held steady. His bow moved with a care Samuel had taught him, drawing warmth from an instrument that could not compete with the expensive violins around him. He played the difficult passage at a measured pace, refusing to race through the notes to impress anyone. A young cellist in the accompanying ensemble lowered his own bow for a moment, listening too closely to count.

Halfway through the excerpt, the bow hair caught on a damaged patch of string. Isaiah heard the scrape and adjusted rather than pretending nothing had happened. He recovered the phrase, allowing the melody to breathe. The error cost him polish, but it revealed the discipline behind his playing. Leonard’s expression changed. He had heard talented children all morning. Here was a child listening to the music as it happened, not merely repeating what had been drilled into him.

The passage had been chosen to expose hurried fingers and uncertain breathing. Isaiah knew its shape from evenings when Samuel played the melody slowly until the kitchen grew still. Yet knowledge did not erase nerves. He felt the unfamiliar space beneath his feet and the uncomfortable heat of the overhead lights. He thought about how one careless sound could become the only sound a powerful person remembered. Still.

At the end nobody applauded. Auditions were not concerts, and the silence seemed larger than the room. Harlan tapped his pen. “Promising instinct,” he said, in a tone that meant the opposite. “But an instrument like that cannot meet professional standards.” Isaiah felt the blood rise in his face. Before he could put away the violin, an elderly judge with silver spectacles spoke from the back row: “Then why did your own concertmaster stop playing to hear him?”

Dr. Margaret Weller, retired concertmaster and the oldest member of the jury, stood so the students could see her. “A young musician can learn technique,” she said. “You cannot measure his future by the price of his case.” Harlan warned that personal sympathy had no place in scholarship decisions. Margaret agreed. “That is why I am asking for an evaluation, not charity.” She requested that Isaiah sight-read a short passage none of the applicants had practiced.