Then he nodded once.

“Fine,” he said. “Then no one should object when it’s time to remember it clearly.”

Landon’s expression changed first. The color seemed to leave his face. Rowan suddenly took a long drink without looking at anyone. Blake shifted his weight and stared at the floor. I should have recognized that none of them heard Felix’s words as a joke.

But I was embarrassed, and embarrassment made me meaner than I wanted to admit.

“You’re making everyone uncomfortable,” I snapped. “You’re acting like I did something unforgivable.”

Felix looked at me for a moment. Not angry. Not pleading. Just disappointed in a way I didn’t know how to handle. Then he turned around and left the room.

No argument followed him. No slammed door. No speech about respect or marriage or boundaries. He simply walked away and left me standing there with people who had stopped laughing.

The gathering continued, technically. But the energy was gone. Conversations became quiet. Landon left earlier than I expected. Rowan and Blake didn’t stay long after that.

Even then, I convinced myself Felix had ruined the mood by being overly sensitive. That night, he came to bed without picking a fight.

Chapter 2

I waited for him to say something while he changed clothes. I waited after the lights went out. I even expected him to turn toward me and ask why I had humiliated him in his own home. He said nothing.

The next morning was worse because it felt so normal. Felix made coffee. He asked if I needed anything from the grocery store after work. Before he left, he kissed my forehead the same way he always did. I stood in the kitchen holding my mug, almost relieved.

See? I told myself. He knows it wasn’t a big deal.

By the second day, I had fully decided he had moved on. I met my friend Paige Winslow for lunch and told her about the party. I laughed while I described Felix’s reaction, making it sound like he had spoiled an innocent joke because he couldn’t take a little teasing. Paige didn’t laugh as much as I expected.

“You really think he was upset about a game?” she asked.

“What else would it be?” I said. “Everybody knew what it was.”

But even as I said it, I remembered Felix’s eyes moving around that room. I remembered the way Landon had gone quiet. I remembered Rowan avoiding my gaze as he headed out the door. I pushed the memory aside.

Over the next few days, I made a point of acting normal around Felix. He did the same. He went to work. He came home. We ate dinner. We talked about routine things.

But there was something different in his silence. It wasn’t the silence of a man waiting to be comforted. It was the silence of a man who had stopped asking for anything.

Then Thursday evening came. Felix arrived home earlier than usual with that envelope in his hand. No flowers. No takeout. No distracted smile while he checked his phone. Just the envelope.