“You think I helped them steal from you?” I said.

“I think you saw enough to know something wasn’t right,” he answered. “And instead of asking a question, you turned the whole night into a distraction.”

“That is not fair.”

“No,” Felix said. “It isn’t.”

His voice never rose, and that made it worse. I threw the papers onto the table.

“Then tell me what you think happened.”

He finally looked at me.

“I think Blake came to this house already knowing where that folder was. I think Rowan knew why he wanted it. And I think Landon figured it out after he got home, which is why he stopped returning your calls.”

I wanted to call Landon immediately. I wanted him to deny all of it, to tell Felix he was blowing another ordinary thing out of proportion. But when I picked up my phone, I saw six calls I had made over the past three days sitting unanswered beneath his name. The last call had gone to voicemail after one ring. I had assumed he was avoiding me because he felt awkward about the party. Now I wondered if he was afraid.

“Why didn’t you tell me any of this?” I asked Felix.

His jaw tightened for the first time.

“Because I needed to know whether you would come to me on your own.”

I hated that answer because part of me understood it. I had noticed the strange silences. I had seen Landon’s face change when Felix spoke at the party. I had watched Rowan leave without saying goodbye. I had felt Blake’s eyes on me the next morning when he sent a joke about the night.

And I had chosen the easiest version of every warning. I picked up the remaining pages from the envelope. There were only three left. The next page was a copy of a building access report from Felix’s office downtown. It showed that someone had used his employee badge after hours on Tuesday night, while he was at dinner with me across town. My stomach dropped.

“That’s impossible,” I said.

Felix gave a humorless laugh.

“I thought so too.”

At the bottom of the report was a grainy image from the lobby security camera. The person’s face was hidden beneath a baseball cap, but the coat was unmistakable. It was mine. I had worn that camel-colored coat on Tuesday. I had lent it to Paige earlier that day when she said she was cold.

Slowly, I turned the page over. Written across the back in Felix’s handwriting were four words that made me stop breathing.

“Paige was there too.”

The words on the back of the report kept pulling my eyes back to them. Paige was there too. I looked at Felix, waiting for him to tell me I had misunderstood.

“You think Paige used my coat to get into your building?”

“I think the camera caught someone wearing it,” he said. “I think Paige knew enough about my schedule to know when I’d be away. And I think she has been asking questions neither of us noticed.”