“I didn’t know he was going to send it anywhere.”

Felix’s expression didn’t change.

“That isn’t what Landon said you knew.”

“I knew he was recording the party,” I said quickly. “Everybody records stupid things at parties. I thought it would stay between us.”

“Between who?”

The question landed harder than it should have. I stared back at the page, but the words had started to blur. I remembered Blake standing near the island with his phone angled too high. I remembered noticing the tiny red dot in the corner of his screen. I remembered deciding it didn’t matter because I looked confident, carefree, untouchable.

I had not asked Landon if he wanted to be on camera. I had not asked Rowan. I had not even thought to ask. Under Landon’s statement was a screenshot of a message thread. The names had been covered with thick black bars, but I recognized the timing. It was from the morning after the party.

One message read:

“Take it down.”

Another said:

“I’m serious. Delete it.”

Then came Blake’s reply:

“Relax. Nobody can tell it was planned.”

A strange pressure built behind my ribs.

“Planned?” I whispered.

Felix pulled the second page from the envelope and laid it in front of me. This one was a photo. Not of the kissing challenge. Not of me. It showed the hallway outside Felix’s home office, taken from a camera I had forgotten we even had.

The timestamp was 9:18 p.m., less than twenty minutes before Felix came back into the living room and found us. Blake stood near the office door. Rowan was beside him, looking over his shoulder. And I was at the end of the hall, turned toward them. The office door was open.

I felt my face drain.

“That doesn’t prove anything.”

“No,” Felix said quietly. “It proves you knew they were back there.”

I grabbed the photo and looked closer. My hand was raised, fingers curled around the stem of a wineglass. I was laughing at something. Blake had one shoulder inside the office. Rowan was watching the kitchen, like he was making sure no one came down the hall.

I remembered that moment now. Not clearly. Not the way I remembered the party games. But enough. Blake had said he wanted to see Felix’s new desk setup.

Rowan had followed him. I had gone after them because I was bored with the conversation in the kitchen and because I wanted to know why they suddenly got quiet when I walked closer. I had found them standing near Felix’s desk. His laptop was closed. The desk drawer was open.

And Blake had been holding a dark-blue folder I had never seen before.

“What was in that folder?” I asked.

Felix looked toward the window instead of at me.

“That’s what I’ve been trying to find out.”

The kitchen seemed to shrink around us.

Chapter 4

I had expected proof that I embarrassed my husband. I had expected some humiliating collection of screenshots, maybe a message from Landon saying he felt uncomfortable. I had prepared myself to apologize for a careless night. I had not prepared for Felix to suggest that something had been taken from his office.