“What is that?” I asked him.

He pulled out a chair but didn’t sit down.

“Open it.”

I crossed my arms.

“Felix, if this is about the kissing prank again—”

“Don’t call it that yet.”

His voice wasn’t loud, but it stopped me cold. I looked at the envelope again. It was plain white, sealed shut, and thick enough that there was more than one sheet inside. My stomach tightened for reasons I couldn’t explain.

“You’ve been acting like everything was fine,” I said.

“No,” he replied. “I’ve been giving you time to notice that it wasn’t.”

That hurt more than anger would have. I reached across the table and picked it up. Felix didn’t try to stop me. He just watched, his face unreadable, while I slid my finger beneath the flap.

For the first time since that party, I understood why he hadn’t argued with me in front of his friends. He hadn’t walked away because he had nothing to say. He had walked away because he was preparing to show me something. Inside the envelope was a stack of papers. I pulled out the first page, and my eyes caught on the opening lines before I could make myself read any further.

Somewhere in the days after that gathering, one of Felix’s closest friends had stopped answering my calls. And as Felix stood across from me in our kitchen, I realized the envelope might finally tell me why.

The first page was not a letter from Felix. It was a printed statement with Landon’s name at the bottom. For a second, I thought it had to be some kind of joke. Landon hated paperwork, hated conflict, and had spent most of the last few years avoiding anything that required him to say what he actually felt. But there it was in clean black type, dated the morning after our party.

He wrote that he had not agreed to be part of anything filmed. My hands went cold.

“What does this mean?” I asked.

Chapter 3

Felix rested both palms on the back of the chair across from me.

“Keep reading.”

I didn’t want to. I already understood enough to know the envelope was not about whether Felix had been jealous. It was about the moment I had turned a room full of people into entertainment and assumed their laughter meant consent.

Landon’s statement described the beginning of the night differently than I remembered it. He said Blake had taken out his phone before the so-called challenge started. He said Rowan asked whether they were recording, and Blake answered that it was only for the group chat. Landon wrote that he had tried to leave it alone because he didn’t want to make things awkward in front of me.

Then there was one sentence I had to read three times. He wrote that I had seen Blake holding the phone up and told everyone to “make it look natural.” I looked up at Felix.