When a widow named Mrs. Abbott explained that her chimney had collapsed, Antoinette had it written down before the woman finished speaking. Gradually, the tenants came to love her. Some brought her eggs wrapped in cloth or a jar of honey saved from summer. Others sought her out to ask her opinion on rents and seed and the coming spring.
William watched the change with a quiet gladness he did not entirely understand. He found himself looking for her across the farmyard, listening for her voice among the others, pleased in a way that had nothing to do with grain. Margaret watched it all, too, from the high windows of the hall. Her plan, eleven years in the making, was crumbling before her eyes. The girl she had buried was rising, and soon the whole county would know it.
Caroline grew angrier with every passing day as she saw William spend his hours with his wife instead of with her. In Caroline’s eyes, Antoinette deserved none of it: not the gown, not the seat at the table, and certainly not the devotion of a duke. Her resentment curdled day by day into venom. And one evening, when William had not yet come down to the dining room, Caroline found Antoinette alone on the great staircase.
Night had fallen over Ravenshire Hall, and the candles along the grand staircase flickered in their sconces, throwing long, restless shadows across the paneled walls. Outside, snow was falling heavily again, pressing against the windows in soft gray drifts. Antoinette had just left the library, the latest ledger tucked under her arm, and was on her way down to dinner. She had almost reached the landing when Caroline stepped out of the shadows in a gown of rose-colored silk and placed herself squarely in her path.
“Don’t get too comfortable, Antoinette,” she said sweetly.
Antoinette stopped. Caroline came closer, one step and then another, until Antoinette could smell her perfume.
“Do you really think William cares about you?”
Antoinette’s voice was quiet. “He has always treated me kindly.”
Caroline laughed, a bright, cruel sound that echoed off the stone. “Men treat their horses kindly, too.”
She tilted her head, her gaze settling on the mark on Antoinette’s cheek.
“He married you for Father’s money. Nothing more. When he looks at you, he sees a bag of gold with a dirty face.”
Antoinette tried to keep her composure. She told herself that Caroline had always been spiteful, that these were only words. But each word struck straight at the fear Margaret had planted in her for eleven years: the fear that she was something to be endured rather than loved. Caroline saw the blow and pressed on.
“Wait until he meets a beautiful woman in London this spring. You’ll see. Then you’ll go back up to the attic where you belong.”
With a swish of rose silk, she turned and swept down the stairs, leaving the faint sweetness of her perfume hanging in the cold air. Antoinette stood motionless, gripping the banister so hard her knuckles turned white. A lock of hair slipped loose from its pins and fell across her face. And out of old habit, without even thinking, she reached up and drew it across her cheek, hiding the mark. It was the same gesture she had made ten thousand times in the attic, the gesture of a girl who had learned that the safest face was a hidden one.
A few minutes later, William found her there, and he knew at once that something was wrong.