“Antoinette,” he said, climbing the stairs as quickly as his leg allowed. “What happened?”

She shook her head. “Nothing, Your Grace.”

He did not press her, for he had learned by now that she would tell him things in her own time. But he noticed the lock of hair drawn across her cheek, exactly as she had worn it on their wedding night, and he understood more than she had said. Gently, without a word, he reached out and brushed the hair aside, tucking it behind her ear so her face was no longer hidden. He did not give a speech, and he did not ask who had hurt her. He simply offered her his arm, and after a moment’s hesitation, Antoinette laid her hand upon it.

William led her into the dining room. Margaret, Caroline and the evening’s guests were already seated, and every head turned as they entered. Before them all, William drew out his wife’s chair and waited until she was settled before taking his own. Throughout dinner, he spoke only to her. He asked about the farms, about the latest pages of the ledgers, about the repairs on the tenant cottages and whether the timber from Whitby had arrived.

He listened to her answers with genuine interest and asked thoughtful questions in return. He did not look at Caroline even once. Little by little, Antoinette’s heartbeat slowed, and her hands stopped trembling. Sitting beside him, speaking of things she understood well, she realized for the first time that she did not need to hide from anyone’s eyes. Caroline’s words had been cruel, but William’s silence toward Caroline spoke louder than anything he could have said aloud.

After that night, Antoinette never again used her hair to cover the mark on her cheek. In the days that followed, they went on managing the estate together. William noticed that he had begun to look forward to their conversations, the long hours in the library with the ledgers spread between them, her quick mind meeting his own. Antoinette, for her part, slowly learned to trust him. But Margaret had not given up.

Two weeks after the wedding, she quietly summoned a lawyer from London to Ravenshire. Then she announced with great warmth that she would host a gathering to formally welcome the new duchess into Yorkshire society. Antoinette was touched, even hopeful. She had no idea that the celebration meant to honor her was in truth a trap, carefully laid to drive her out of Ravenshire Hall forever.

On a bitter Tuesday afternoon, the noble families of the district arrived at Ravenshire Hall. Their carriages came one after another up the long drive, wheels crunching through the snow, horses steaming in the frozen air. Inside, the great hall blazed with candles. Margaret moved among her guests in black velvet and pearls, gracious and smiling, telling anyone who would listen that tonight they celebrated Antoinette’s arrival as the Duchess of Ravenshire.

Antoinette wore the blue gown William had ordered from York. She stood at her husband’s side, still unused to so many eyes upon her, her fingers resting lightly on his sleeve. Many seemed surprised, even disappointed, to find an ordinary young woman instead of the monster they had heard about for years. William kept close to her, nodding to the squires and their wives. Then his eyes fell on a stranger near the fireplace, a sharp-featured man in a dark coat who held a leather case of documents against his chest.

When William asked Mr. Finch who he was, the old solicitor’s face went pale. It was Mr. Richard Vale, a lawyer from London. When all the guests had gathered and the wine had been poured, Vale rose and asked for everyone’s attention. The murmur of conversation faded.