“I deeply regret,” he said in a smooth, carrying voice, “that I must announce a serious error in the interpretation of the late duke’s will.”

William turned to look at Margaret. She wore an expression of gentle sorrow, as though she had nothing whatever to do with what was happening. Vale opened his case and drew out a copy of the will. The clause was clear, he explained: the heir was required to marry the late duke’s daughter, but Antoinette Whitcomb was not Henry Hawthorne’s daughter. She was the child of his first wife by another man.

By Vale’s reading of the law, this marriage did not satisfy the condition at all, and therefore the entire fortune must pass to Lady Margaret and Lady Caroline. A low ripple of shock and excitement spread from one end of the hall to the other. William stepped forward.

“The late duke always called Antoinette his daughter,” he said. “Everyone in this county knows it.”

Vale regarded him calmly. “Does Your Grace possess any proof in the late duke’s own hand of what he meant by that word?”

William fell silent. He had never seen any such document, and he had never thought to look for one. Vale seized on the silence at once.

“Then there is no basis for Your Grace’s interpretation. The law reads the words as they are written.”

Margaret rose then, her face a mask of grief. It would be best for everyone, she said, if Antoinette went away. She proposed sending her to a quiet residence for poor gentlewomen near Harrogate, a respectable place where she could live out her days in peace.

“She will be safe there,” Margaret said softly. “Out of sight of society, just as before.”

Then she turned her gaze toward William.

“And you, Your Grace, may ask the church to consider ending this unfortunate marriage and find a wife more suited to your station.”

As she spoke, her eyes flicked toward Caroline. It lasted only an instant, but William saw it. Antoinette had gone white. Her hands were trembling again, exactly as they had on her wedding night. She felt the walls of the attic closing around her once more: the narrow window, the cold, the silence, the years stretching out without end.

She had tasted freedom for barely two weeks, and now it was being stripped away in front of the very people she had hoped might one day accept her. Everything in her wanted to vanish. She turned to William, and her voice came out barely above a whisper.

“You married me for the money. Now the money is gone.” Her voice faltered further. “You don’t need to keep me.”

The great hall fell utterly silent. Not a glass clinked, and not a skirt rustled. Every eye in the room was fixed on the Duke of Ravenshire. William looked at the woman standing beside him, at the gray eyes shining with tears she refused to let fall, at the small brown mark she no longer hid, and in that moment he understood something he had not yet found the courage to name during those two weeks of ledgers and snowy fields and quiet firelit evenings. Across the hall, Margaret allowed herself the smallest smile, certain that he would choose the fortune and the future of a duke over a wife who no longer brought him any profit.

William drew himself up to his full height. He turned and looked directly at Margaret.

“No,” he said.

Margaret’s smile widened slightly. “Then you agree, Your Grace, that Antoinette should go.”