“Do not be clever with me just now,” Prudence said.

He shut his mouth. She opened the little leather case. She took the gold watch from its green velvet bedding and held it out toward him across the space between them, in front of all the tenants of the Caro estate.

“Your watch, Your Grace,” she said clearly. “Commissioned in April 1812. Completed in August 1818. Balance owing, sixty pounds.”

The hall was so quiet that one could hear the beef fat sizzling in the kitchen. At first he did not take it. He looked at the climbing roses around the case and the single full-blown rose above the six others. Something passed across his face. Then he took it carefully in both hands.

“Pinchbeck,” he said without turning around, “bring me sixty pounds from my desk.”

The butler, who had been propped upright on a bench, staggered to his feet and hurried away.

“Prue. Miss Tolliver. Mrs. Lyle…” he began, but she was finished.

At last Coyle found his voice.

“Your Grace,” he said, his tone suddenly oily, “there has clearly been a misunderstanding, but the law is the law. That watch is my security. That woman was promised to me in writing, and she has lied to the entire district about being married. That cannot be denied.”

“No,” the Duke said calmly. “It cannot. It was a lie. I told it myself in the yard of the Bull at Stony Stratford, in the space of about one second.”

He looked straight at Coyle.

“I will say so again.”

A murmur ran along the tables.

“But I cannot sit as magistrate in a case involving my own watch and my own lie,” the Duke continued. “That would be neither fair nor lawful. Sir Hector,” he said, turning toward the stout man in the red waistcoat, “you are a justice of the peace for this county. Will you hear the matter?”

Sir Hector Bellamy of Bellamy Grange, near Towcester, was a fair-minded, stubborn man. He had sat on the bench for thirty years. Until about ninety seconds ago he had never been cheated at whist.

“I will hear it,” he said gruffly, “tomorrow at eleven, in the back room of the Caro Arms. Everyone is to bring their papers.”

He fixed the Duke with a sharp stare.

“And, Your Grace, that watch is to be locked away and untouched until then. It lies at the heart of the whole business.”

“It will be in my desk,” said the Duke. “Locked. Pinchbeck has the only remaining key.”

Pinchbeck returned with sixty pounds in a small cloth bag. Prudence counted the money there and then, coin by coin, on the edge of the card table. She took exactly sixty pounds, not a penny more or less. Then she turned and left the great hall without looking back.

Prudence did not get very far, however. She had reached the foot of the front steps when a small, sharp hand caught her elbow, and she found herself looking into the face of the old lady in purple silk.

“Lady Augusta Lyle,” said the old lady, the Duke’s aunt. “I cheat at cards. I suppose he has told you.”

“Yes, my lady,” Prudence said stiffly.

“Good. Then he has told you one true thing about this family.”

Lady Augusta looked her up and down.

“You will stay at the dower house with me tonight. No, do not argue. The Caro Arms is full of farmers, and the pawnbroker has a room above the taproom. I will not have it.”

“I cannot accept charity from…”

“It is not charity, girl. I want a favor from you.”