“I have waited forty years to do that to someone,” Lady Augusta said cheerfully.

Coyle was on the edge of the table.

“It does not matter!” he shouted. “So my man recovered my own property. It is still my watch. It was pledged to me in February. I have the ticket.”

He slammed the pawn ticket onto the table.

“Thank you,” Prudence said quietly. “I had hoped you would say that.”

She lifted the real watch from its cream silk lining. She held it for a moment as one might hold a small bird. Then she slipped her steel blade beneath the rim and opened the case.

“Sir Hector,” she said, “would you look inside this case through my glass, please?”

Five small marks had been stamped into the gold. Sir Hector bent to look.

“A crown,” he said. “A leopard’s head, I think. The head of a man, the king, I suppose. And a little letter C.”

“Those are the hallmarks of Goldsmiths’ Hall in London,” Prudence said. “Every gold watchcase made in London must be examined and stamped there. The crown and the number eighteen show eighteen-carat gold. The leopard stands for London. The king’s head means the duty has been paid.”

She touched the last tiny mark with the tip of her needle.

“And that little letter is the date. The Hall changes it every year in May. The letter C was first used in May of this year, 1818.”

She looked straight at Barnaby Coyle.

“Your ticket says my father pledged this watch in February,” she said. “Sir, in February this case did not exist. It was a lump of gold in Mr. Deuce’s drawer in Red Lion Street. He made it in June. I have his bill in my father’s daybook. The dial was enameled in June as well. I have that bill too. By then my father had been dead for three months.”

Her voice never shook.

“He could not have pawned it. Nobody could have pawned it. Not in February. It wasn’t a watch yet.”

Coyle opened his mouth. Sir Hector spoke slowly.

“Can anyone confirm for me that the little C is this year’s date letter? I am not a silversmith.”

Pinchbeck cleared his throat.

“I can, sir,” he said. “His Grace ordered new sauceboats from London in August. They bear the little C. I polish them every Thursday.”

He looked at Prudence, and some of the sternness softened in his old face.

“The young lady is quite right.”

Sir Hector put down the glass. He picked up the pawn ticket and examined it for a long time. Then he picked up the other paper, the promise of marriage, signed Amos Tolliver in a beautiful, firm hand.

“Miss Tolliver,” he said, “you told this room that your father could not write a steady line.”

“Not since the spring of 1816, sir.”

She produced a small, battered book from her bag and opened it.

“These are his invoices. All of them since then were signed by me. A. Tolliver, by P. T. And here,” she turned another page, “is the last letter he tried to write himself, in January.”

She placed it beside the promise. Sir Hector looked from one to the other. One page bore a clear, flowing signature. The other showed a broken, wavering scrawl that sloped downhill across the line like rain running down a window.

The magistrate was silent for quite a long time.

“Sir, one thing more,” Prudence said softly, “if you will permit it. There is something no pawnbroker in London could know about this watch. Something only my father and I knew. And one other person.”