Lady Augusta began leading her along the gravel path between two yew hedges.

“I want you to listen to me for fifteen minutes. That is the price of the bed.”

The dower house was small and warm and smelled of woodsmoke and lavender. Lady Augusta sat Prudence beside the fire, gave her a glass of cherry cordial, and seated herself opposite like a judge.

“Six years ago,” Lady Augusta said, “my sister-in-law died in that great house. Robert’s mother. He was twenty-six. He sat beside her bed for nine days. He did not eat. He did not sleep.”

“On the last morning, before dawn, she asked what time he thought it was.”

The old lady’s mouth trembled once.

“He guessed, and she smiled and told him he was wrong as usual. And then she was gone.”

Prudence set down her glass very carefully.

“That watch was meant to be in her hand, so she would never need to ask anyone the time again,” Lady Augusta said. “He could not bear to see it. Do you understand that? It was not carelessness. He told your father to take his time because he could not face the day it came home.”

“I didn’t know,” Prudence whispered.

“No. How could you? He never tells anyone anything. Dreadful, silent, honest boy.”

Lady Augusta leaned forward.

“Now listen to me. I have known Robert Lyle since the day he was born. He has never told a lie in his life. Not one. Not since he was nine years old and lied about eating an entire gooseberry tart. He was sick for two days and swore never to lie again.”

She pointed at Prudence.

“And then a girl he had never met caught his sleeve in a muddy yard, and he told the biggest barefaced lie in Northamptonshire in less than a second. For you.”

She leaned back.

“Think about that, Miss Tolliver. That is all. Think about it.”

She rose, patted Prudence on the head as she might pat a hunting dog, and went out. Prudence sat by the fire for a very long time.

At nearly eleven that night, a little pebble rattled against her window. She opened it. In the cold moonlight the Duke of Caro stood on the gravel path. He wore no hat. His hair was wet. She thought he looked exactly like a man tending a horse, except that there was no horse.

“I shall not come up,” he said. “I won’t even ask you to come down. I only want to say one thing. Then I’ll go.”

She waited.

“You told me you would rather sleep in a ditch than accept charity from a duke,” he said. “I believed you. If I had told you who I was at that inn, you would have walked out into the rain alone while Coyle waited for you.”

He took a breath.

“And that is not all. I’ll be truthful. I liked being the man with the horse. No one has looked at me like that in years, as though I were simply a man. I wanted to keep it for a little longer. That was selfish. I’m sorry.”

Prudence gripped the window frame.

“You should have told me,” she said.

“Yes.”

“I would have been furious.”

“I know you still are.”

“I am,” she agreed.

He nodded as though that were entirely reasonable.

“Tomorrow at eleven,” he said. “I shall be there. I will not speak for you. You have no need of anyone to do that. But I will stand beside you if you allow it.”

He turned and walked down the gravel path before she could answer. She stood at the open window until her hands were cold. Then she closed it slowly and went to bed. She lay awake for a long time.