The silence in the back room of the Caro Arms seemed to come alive.

“Furthermore, Sir Hector, since 1800 the law has required every pawnbroker to keep a book of pledged articles. Every entry, every number, every date, every name. Mr. Coyle brought his book today to show you the February entry for my father’s watch. I saw it in his hand when he came in.”

Sir Hector held out his large, round hand.

“Mr. Coyle. The book.”

“This is outrageous.”

“The book, sir, or I shall have the constable seize it.”

Very slowly Coyle drew a thick brown calfskin ledger from beneath his chair. Sir Hector licked his thumb and turned the pages. At last he spoke.

“Number 2,214.”

He brought the page close to his nose.

“October 30, 1818. One Dutch watch, metal case, pledged by J. Samson. Five shillings.”

He looked up from the book.

“Mr. Coyle, this is in your handwriting, eight days ago.”

A long, low murmur rolled through the room.

“A coincidence,” Coyle said.

His voice rose to a squeak.

“Hundreds of watches pass through my shop. That proves nothing about how it came into His Grace’s possession.”

And just then Mr. Pinchbeck, butler to the Dukes of Caro for thirty-one years, stepped forward from the doorway.

“Sir Hector,” he said in a slightly shaking voice, “I believe I can help with that.”

Everyone turned. Mr. Pinchbeck explained that at seven o’clock that morning a chimney sweep had come to the back door of Caro Park. He had a note signed by the estate steward arranging to sweep the study chimney.

“Our steward is in Kettering. I should have known better. I let the sweep in. I left him alone in the study for four minutes while I fetched more dust sheets.”

His long face was pale with shame.

“Four minutes. I have served thirty-one years, Your Grace. Never once before have I left a stranger alone in that room. When the young lady looked at me just now, I thought what everyone else was thinking.”

Prudence turned in her chair to look at him. Her eyes were full of tears.

“Oh, Mr. Pinchbeck,” she said. “I am so sorry.”

“I thought you suspected me, miss,” he said stiffly. “I had the key.”

“What did this sweep look like?” Sir Hector asked.

“Small, sir. Thin fellow, long nose. Sang a great deal, but badly. ‘The Lass of Richmond Hill.’ He sang the entire thing twice.”

Slowly every eye in the room turned toward Coyle’s two hired men. The large one, Gully, stared at the ceiling. The smaller, thin fellow with the long nose looked pale beneath a gray streak at his hairline that he had missed when he washed his face. His hands were folded on his knees. Every crease of his fingers was black.

“Mr. Thrip, isn’t it?” Prudence said gently. “Would you hold up your hands?”

Thrip looked at his hands. He looked at Coyle. He looked at Prudence, who was gazing back at him without the slightest anger. Then he suddenly shouted.

“I told him the chimney was a stupid idea! I told him! I got stuck twice! There’s a jackdaw’s nest up there the size of a bucket!”

The room exploded into noise. Someone fell off a barrel. Lady Augusta, seated in the front row, laughed so hard that the vicar had to pat her back.

“Constable,” Sir Hector said, wiping his eyes with his great handkerchief, “secure that man and the big fellow before he reaches the window.”

The big fellow had already reached the window. He had one leg over the sill when Lady Augusta extended her walking stick, hooked his remaining ankle, and pulled. He landed on the floor like a sack of turnips.