Eleanor tried to understand. Her parents had lived quietly, far from London society. Her father rented fields and helped repair the village bridge. Her mother delivered soup to sick neighbors and never expected praise. She could not imagine how they had known a duke.

“I remember the scar above his eye,” Westmere said. “And that shawl. I remember the night they wore those clothes.”

Lady Lavinia gave a brittle laugh. “There must be hundreds of people with such names.”

“Not with that scar,” he replied. “Not with that shawl.”

He carefully wrapped the portrait in his clean handkerchief and rose. “Before anyone speaks of Miss Ashford’s marriage, I believe this room deserves to hear what her parents once did.”

Eleanor saw her aunt’s face change. It was not surprise alone. For a fraction of a second, she looked frightened.

—

“Your Grace, surely this can wait,” Lady Lavinia said. “My guests have come to enjoy their supper, not to hear a family history.”

“Then they may enjoy the truth with their supper,” Westmere answered.

Eleanor remained near the hearth. She had been taught never to contradict her aunt before company. Even now, instinct urged her to apologize for the discomfort.

He spoke of a September evening in 1809, when heavy rain swelled the River Lune. He had been traveling north with his mother and younger sister. Their carriage reached an old stone crossing shortly after dusk. A section of the road collapsed beneath the horses, and the carriage slid down the bank into fast water.

“My mother could not swim,” he said. “My sister Cecily was ten. I tried to pull them out, but a wheel pinned my leg.”

Lady Lavinia stared at the carpet.

“A man came down the bank with a rope. His wife followed carrying blankets. They could have gone home and left us to the current. Instead, they risked their lives until we were safe.”

Eleanor remembered her father returning from a storm with an injured shoulder, her mother spending three nights nursing visitors in their spare room. As a girl, she had been told only that travelers had suffered an accident. Her parents did not like being praised for kindness.

“Thomas Ashford carried my sister,” the duke continued. “Marian Ashford kept my mother warm when the fever came. I owe them more than gratitude can express.”

Mr. Harcourt cleared his throat. “A touching story, certainly. But it cannot alter Miss Ashford’s circumstances.”

Westmere looked at him. “No. It alters my understanding of the people who have been describing them.”

Then he asked Eleanor a question that made her aunt grip the back of her chair.

—

“Did you ever receive the letter my mother sent after your father’s death?” the duke asked.