For a heartbeat, neither woman knew whether to shake hands or embrace. Then Evelyn opened her arms. Karen folded into them. Her mother smelled of lavender soap, road dust, and cold air.
“You’re too thin,” Evelyn said.
Karen laughed once through her tears.
“Hello to you, too.”
Evelyn held her at arm’s length.
“Tell me everything in the kitchen.”
Karen did. She told her about Danner, the cut fences, the note, the sheriff. She didn’t soften the story of Thomas’s death either. He’d been thrown from his horse while checking the northern pasture before dawn. The cinch had torn.
At first, Karen blamed old age or bad leather. Then, one of the remaining hands showed her the strap. Near the buckle, a section had been sliced almost clean through, not enough to give way while Thomas was saddling up. Just enough to fail after miles of riding. Evelyn’s face went still.
“Who knew about this?”
“Me. One ranch hand. Sheriff Ames.”
“Danner?”
“I never told him.”
Evelyn looked toward the window.
“Did the sheriff keep the strap?”
“He said he would.”
“Did you watch him log it as evidence?”
Karen shook her head. Evelyn stood. She crossed to the leather case and opened it. Folded clothes came out first. Then Karen caught a smell she hadn’t expected.
Gun oil. Evelyn took out a cleaning rod, an oiled rag, a small box of cartridges. Then dark walnut appeared beneath canvas, and Karen stopped breathing for a moment. Her mother unwrapped a lever-action rifle. The metal was worn at the edges.
Not neglected. Used, maintained, familiar. Evelyn worked the lever once. A clean metallic click cut through the kitchen. Karen stared.
“Mother.”
Evelyn checked the chamber.
“Mhm.”
“Why do you own a Winchester?”
Her mother looked up.
“There’s some history I never told you.”
Karen nearly laughed in disbelief.
“You think?”
Evelyn lowered the rifle.
“Your father knew.”
“That doesn’t make it better.”
“No, I imagine it makes it worse.”
“What history?”
Evelyn sat across from her.
“Before your father. Before Abilene. I worked protection.”
“For whom?”
“Anyone who needed it and could persuade me they were worth protecting.”
“That sounds like gun work.”
“It often was.”
Karen looked at the rifle, then at the woman who had taught her to stitch a hem, put up peaches, and never serve company coffee in a chipped cup.
“How long?”
“About 6 years. And then I met your father.”
Evelyn’s face softened.
“I found I preferred waking beside one man I loved to waking beside a rifle I might need.”
Karen said nothing. Evelyn rested both hands on the table.
“I left that life 26 years ago.”
“Why hide it from me?”
“Because I didn’t want you growing up believing violence was the most interesting thing about your mother.”
The answer hit Karen harder than she expected. Evelyn glanced at the window again.
“But if someone cut Thomas’s saddle strap, this is no longer just a land dispute.”
Her hand settled on the Winchester.
“And if Danner knows more than he should, I mean to find out.”