“No,” Karen said. “I didn’t.”
The remaining riders looked at Danner. Evelyn lowered her voice.
“How did you know?”
Danner’s hand tightened on the reins.
“Everyone in town knows.”
“They know he died,” Evelyn said. “Not how.”
Danner looked toward the road. That was answer enough. Karen’s grief hardened into something sharper.
“Did you cut his saddle strap?”
“No.”
Too fast. Evelyn watched him.
“Then who did?”
His eyes snapped back.
“I said no.”
“You said more than that.”
The scarred rider shifted uneasily. Danner looked at him then at the others. He knew what Evelyn knew. He had lost control of the yard.
“This conversation is over.”
“No,” Karen said. Her own voice surprised her. “It just turned honest.”
Danner stared at her. Karen stepped to the edge of the porch.
“Tell whoever sent you that my land is not for sale.”
Danner said nothing.
“And if the sheriff won’t ask how you knew about Thomas,” she went on, “someone else will.”
Evelyn lowered the Winchester slightly.
“Now the conversation is over.”
Danner wheeled his horse. The remaining men followed. The youngest rider didn’t look back. Dust swallowed them as they left.
Karen stood frozen until the hoofbeats faded. Then her knees gave way. Evelyn caught her elbow.
“Inside.”
“Mother.”
“Inside first.”
Karen looked toward the road.
“Thomas.”
“I know.”
“You think Danner?”
“I think he knows something.” Evelyn’s eyes hardened. “And now he knows we noticed.”
Sheriff Ames arrived before sunset. Evelyn had sent a boy from the neighboring ranch to fetch him with a message simple enough that even a reluctant lawman couldn’t ignore it. “Bring Thomas Ashby’s saddle strap.” The sheriff came without it. Evelyn saw that before he even dismounted.
“Where’s the strap?”
Ames looked at Karen.
“Mrs. Ashby…”
“The strap.”
“I may have misplaced it.”
Karen stared.
“You lost the evidence in my husband’s death.”
“I didn’t say evidence.”
Evelyn stepped off the porch.
“No, you said misplaced.”
Ames eyed the Winchester leaning against the porch post.
“Threatening an officer is a poor idea.”
Evelyn’s face stayed calm.
“Good thing no one has threatened you.”
Karen came down the steps.
“Danner knew Thomas died in a riding accident.”
Ames went still. Evelyn saw it. So did Karen.
“Well, I’m the sheriff.”
“And Karen,” Evelyn said, “she was his wife. Who else would have told him?”
Ames looked away. Karen’s voice cracked.
“Walter.”
The sheriff rubbed a hand over his face. For the first time, he looked less corrupt than tired and afraid.
“Danner came to me after Thomas died.”
Karen stepped closer.
“Why?”
“He wanted to know what I’d found.”
“And what did you tell him?”
Ames said nothing. Evelyn answered for him.
“You told him about the strap.”
The sheriff’s silence confirmed it.
“Did he pay you?”
Ames stared at the ground. Karen closed her eyes.
“How much was my husband worth?”
“Karen…”
“How much?”
“$50.”
She slapped him. The sound was small beside the rifle shot from earlier, but it carried more force. Ames didn’t raise a hand. Karen’s eyes filled.