“You sold him for $50.”

“I didn’t kill Thomas.”

“No,” Evelyn said. “You only made certain the man who might have helped us find out who did could sleep soundly.”

Ames looked at her.

“I still have something.”

He reached slowly into his coat. Evelyn’s hand drifted toward the rifle. The sheriff pulled out a folded paper.

“Danner gave me names, properties, people his consortium wanted pressured.”

Karen took it. Her own ranch was third on the list. Five others followed. Evelyn read every line.

“This isn’t a land buying operation.”

Ames nodded.

“It’s a squeeze.”

“Water control,” Karen said.

The sheriff looked ashamed.

“They buy or pressure every property that touches the creek. Once they hold the crossings, they decide who gets water downstream.”

Evelyn folded the paper.

“Who’s behind it?”

“A company called Western Plains Development.”

“Cheyenne?”

“Yes.”

“Names.”

Ames hesitated. Evelyn stared at him.

“You’ve already sold one truth. Decide what the next one costs.”

The sheriff looked at Karen, then finally spoke.

“Silas Vane.”

Evelyn’s expression changed. Karen noticed.

“You know him?”

“No.”

But the way she said it meant something else. Evelyn folded the paper once more.

“I know the type.”

Evelyn could have gone after Danner. 20 years earlier, she might have. Instead, she spent the next morning at Karen’s kitchen table with documents spread across the wood. Tax receipts, land surveys, old cattle bills. Thomas’s notes, a map of the creek. Karen watched her mother work.

“No rifle?”

Evelyn looked up.

“A rifle solved yesterday’s problem.”

“And today’s?”

“Paper.”

Karen almost laughed.

“After everything you told me about Dakota Territory, your next weapon is paperwork.”

“The older I get, the fonder I grow of weapons that don’t need cleaning.”

By noon, they had a plan. Sheriff Ames would sign a sworn statement. So would Karen. So would the neighboring rancher whose fences had been cut, too. The old rider who’d abandoned Danner in the yard agreed to testify that Danner had arrived with hired guns to force a sale.

Most important of all, Ames had kept one letter from Western Plains Development, instructing him not to interfere in private negotiations involving certain ranches. Silas Vane’s signature was at the bottom. Evelyn sent copies in three directions. One to a territorial judge, one to a newspaper editor in Cheyenne, one to Western Plains itself. The letter to the company was the shortest.

“Your agent brought armed men to the Ashby Ranch. Evidence of bribery and coercion has been copied and sent beyond this county. Any further threat to Karen Ashby or her neighbors will become public record before your men can reach the county line.”

Karen read it.

“You didn’t mention the Winchester.”

Evelyn looked at her.

“Reputation works best when the other side supplies that part themselves.”

Three days passed. No riders came. On the fourth, a telegram arrived. Western Plains denied ever authorizing violence. It had dismissed Royce Danner and it offered to negotiate a legal water easement at market value. Karen read the telegram twice.