Before we go back to Karen and Evelyn, it’s worth understanding something about land disputes in the American West. In remote ranching country, the law could exist on paper and still feel a very long way off. A single sheriff might be responsible for enormous stretches of territory, and witnesses were scarce. Cattle interests, land companies, speculators, and local officials could lean hard on small owners who lacked money or political weight. Water made those fights even more dangerous.
A creek crossing one ranch might decide whether a handful of other properties survived a dry season. Access, irrigation, grazing, and water rights could be worth as much as the land itself. And in isolated communities, protection didn’t always arrive in the shape people expected. Sometimes it came from neighbors. Sometimes from family, sometimes from someone whose past had taught them skills they’d hoped never to use again.
4 days after Evelyn arrived, seven horses came up the road. Karen heard them before she saw them. Hooves pounding packed earth, bits jingling, leather creaking. Then dust rose beyond the gate.
Royce Danner rode in front with six men behind him. These were no clerks from Cheyenne. They wore their revolvers low. Two had rifles in saddle scabbards.
One had a scar running from his left ear toward his jaw. Karen recognized another from town, a man who’d once broken a bartender’s nose over a card game and laughed while the blood was mopped off the floor. Hired guns. Danner had stopped pretending.
Karen stepped onto the porch and Evelyn came to stand beside her. The rifle stayed inside. That surprised Karen. Danner reined in.
“Mrs. Ashby.”
“Mr. Danner.”
His gaze moved to Evelyn.
“Heard you sent for help.”
“My mother.”
Danner studied her.
“This is what came?”
The youngest rider laughed.
“That old woman is your protection.”
The others joined in.
“Ma’am, no offense, but you’d be safer with a dog.”
Evelyn waited. The wind stirred her shawl. Then she asked about the iron dinner bell.
“How far?”
The riders glanced at it.
“65 yards,” Evelyn said.
The young man leaned forward in his saddle.
“You planning to ring it from here?”
“If I need to.”
Danner smiled.
“You expect us to be impressed?”
“No.” Evelyn looked at him. “I expect you to explain why you brought six armed men to my daughter’s home.”
Danner’s smile faded.
“I brought witnesses.”
The scarred rider laughed. Evelyn’s eyes flicked to him.
“Witnesses don’t usually carry rifles to a legal negotiation.”
Danner shifted in his saddle.
“My employers want this matter settled.”
“Your employers can make an offer.”
“They did.”
“You made a threat.”
Danner turned to Karen.
“Mrs. Ashby has had time to reconsider.”
“I have,” Karen said. “And no.”
The youngest gunman muttered something and nudged his horse forward half a step. Evelyn’s gaze fixed on him.
“Stay where you are.”
He grinned.
“Or what?”
Evelyn reached beneath her shawl. The Winchester came up without hurry, and that frightened the men more than speed would have. No fumbling, no flourish, only practiced ease. The laughter died. She held the rifle low across her body. Danner’s horse tossed its head.