“66 pounds of coal that evaporated,” said Sir Henry. “Go on.”
“The second matter is flour. 19 days before I left, Mr. Garrow reported 30 sacks spoiled by a flood in the lower granary and bought 30 more from Pell. 45 pounds.”
Mrs. Dunning marched across the room and set the canvas sack in front of the magistrate with enormous satisfaction.
“One of the so-called spoiled ones, sir. Chaff and sawdust with a dusting on top. Holloway’s mill stamp. We never bought a sack from Holloway’s in my 19 years. And that granary sits 2 feet above the yard on solid stone. It’s never flooded in its life.”
Garrow’s voice stayed calm, but it had become a little faster.
“Then Pell has cheated the estate and I was deceived. I am an old man, Sir Henry, and I trusted a contractor I had used for years. That is a failure of judgment, not a crime.”
It was a good answer. Rose had known he would have one good answer. That was why she had kept the third matter for last.
“The third matter is timber. Mr. Fenwick?”
The solicitor laid the two bank drafts side by side.
“March, 112 pounds to Pell for oak timber for tenant roofing. April, 112 pounds to Pell for roofing oak, North cottages. Both signed by you, Mr. Garrow. Not by Pell. By you. A man deceived by a carter does not write the same bill twice with his own hand.”
For the first time Garrow did not answer.
“And Mrs. Abney’s roof was on that list,” Rose added quietly. “It has leaked for 3 years. Her letter is here, Sir Henry. And 11 men are waiting in the yard for money they have been promised every Lady Day since the old Duke died.”
Garrow had gone pale. But he was not finished. Rose saw him gather himself and she knew what he would do before he opened his mouth.
“Sir Henry you should know who brings these accusations. This young woman left His Grace’s household in haste a week ago. Since then His Grace has visited her every day at a public inn. He pays her two guineas a week. Before you take the word of a servant against 23 years of faithful service you ought to ask what that servant is to her master. Because everyone in Wexley…”
“Stop,” said the Duke.
He did not raise his voice. He did not stand. But even the magistrate turned his head.
“You will not speak of her in that tone again, Garrow. Miss Calder was paid by my solicitor’s office for the work you have just watched her do. She has paid her own lodging every night and met me only before witnesses. And if you wish to talk about letters…”
Mr. Fenwick laid the anonymous note from the Bell Inn and the scrap from Ledbury on the table. Then he took one more object from his folder and set it down beside them. The estate office seal. A sheaf of wheat in a ring with a piece missing at the top right.
“Taken from your desk this morning by Mr. Price before two witnesses,” said the solicitor. “It carries a chip His Grace made when he was nine years old. The same chip is in the wax on both of these letters.”
Sir Henry picked up the seal and pressed it gently against the broken wax. It fitted like a key in a lock. He set it down very slowly.
“Mr. Garrow, I have known you 20 years. I will tell you plainly, I have never been so disappointed in a man. You stole from families with leaking roofs. And when a young woman found you out, you tried to destroy her good name to save your own.”