“Thank you,” she said.

“Do not thank me yet. I have not decided whether I am being wise or a fool.”

“Most men find it hard to tell the difference, Your Grace.”

For the smallest moment, she almost smiled. Then the carrier’s cart rolled up and Rose Calder walked out of Hallamere House without looking back. The Duke stood in the doorway and watched the cart until it turned out of the drive toward the market town of Wexley. Only then did he look down at the silver tray. The brass key lay where she had left it.

It was an old key, worn thin at the teeth from three years of turning in the storeroom lock every morning before dawn. Around its bow, someone had tied a short loop of green thread so it could be found quickly in the dark. He picked it up. It was still warm from her hand. Behind him, a voice cleared its throat.

“A sad business, Your Grace, but perhaps for the best.”

It was Silas Garrow, the estate steward. Garrow had managed the Hallamere lands for 23 years. He had served the old Duke before Thomas inherited. He was a broad, gray-whiskered man with a soft voice and very clean hands, and he signed every bill that the estate paid.

“For the best,” the Duke said. “Explain that to me, Garrow.”

Garrow lowered his voice as if sharing a kindness.

“I would not speak ill of the young woman, but there has been talk in the servants’ hall. A man in town, I am told, some private attachment.”

“Did she tell you that?”

“Not in so many words, Your Grace.”

“Then in how many words?”

Garrow only smiled thinly.

“I see,” said the Duke. “Thank you, Garrow. That will be all.”

When the steward had gone back down the corridor to the estate office, the Duke climbed the stairs to his study. Her letter lay on the blotter, exactly where she had said it would be. It was short. It thanked him for three years of fair employment.

It listed the state of every store in the house. And the last line said something that made him read it three times. “I leave this post so that no harm will come to this house or to its master. I ask you, as the last thing I shall ever ask, not to ride the north road to the tenant cottages until after the frost.” There was nothing in it about a man in town. There was nothing in it about a private attachment.

There was a warning. That was when he understood that Silas Garrow had just lied to his face. The Duke rang the bell. When Price appeared, the Duke held up the letter.

“Price, did anyone come to the house today who should not have been here?”

The old butler considered the question with great care, as he considered everything.

“There is the back gate book, Your Grace. Miss Calder started it 2 years ago. Every cart that comes through the service gate is written down. The time, the carter’s name, the load. She said that a house which pays for goods ought to know whether the goods arrived.”

“Bring it to me.”

The back gate book was a plain ledger with a cracked leather spine. Every line ruled in Rose’s tidy hand. The Duke ran his finger down that morning’s page. “7:00, butcher’s boy, mutton. 9:00, laundry cart, linen returned. 11:00, J. Pell, no load, business with the steward.” And beside that line, in smaller letters, she had written one more word. “Unexpected.”

“Who is J. Pell?”