“Every load of coal that came through the service gate, I wrote down myself or had the gate boy write down while I watched. In the same 6 months, 38 loads arrived, not 60.”

“38.”

Mr. Fenwick took off his spectacles.

“22 loads paid for and never delivered.”

“£66,” said Rose. “Paid out of the Hallamere accounts for coal that does not exist.”

The Duke turned from the window.

“£66 would have bought new thatch for eight cottages.”

“11,” said Rose, “if you buy the straw before the frost, when it is cheaper.”

The solicitor almost laughed. He looked at the Duke.

“Your Grace,” he said dryly, “I think you have engaged the right examiner.”

“I have been told,” said the Duke, “that I occasionally make good decisions.”

“Occasionally,” said Rose without looking up.

At 4:00 that afternoon, a groom from Hallamere rode into Wexley at a gallop and came pounding up the stairs to the solicitor’s chambers, breathless and white.

“Your Grace, begging pardon, it’s the light gig, the one you take to the north cottages. Mr. Price told us to look it over like you asked.”

“The near side linchpin…”

He swallowed.

“It’s been filed, Your Grace, halfway through. It would have held on the flat. It wouldn’t have held on a hill.”

The room went very quiet. The Duke put both hands flat on the window sill and stood for a long moment with his head down. Then he turned and looked at Rose.

“You were right,” he said, “and I would have been on that road on Thursday.”

Rose’s hands were shaking. She folded them on the table so no one would see.

“Keep it locked,” she said, “please.”

“Locked with the key in my own pocket. And the groom will sign a statement for Mr. Fenwick before he leaves this room.”

On the fourth day, there was an unexpected visitor at the solicitor’s chambers. Mrs. Dunning came up the narrow stairs with her best bonnet on her head and a lumpy canvas sack over her shoulder. She was puffing hard. She dropped the sack on Mr. Fenwick’s polished floor with a thump.

“That’s the one,” she announced. “The one Miss Calder told me to keep back from the so-called flooded granary. I’ve had it in my larder behind the pickled onions for 19 days and I’m sick of looking at it.”

Rose knelt beside the sack. She untied the string and opened the neck. It was not rotten flour. It was not flour at all. It was chaff and sawdust packed tight with a thin layer of gray flour across the top.

“And look here,” said Mrs. Dunning pointing a stubby finger at the stamp on the canvas. “That’s the mark of Holloway’s Mill at Ashby. We don’t buy from Holloway’s, never have. Our flour comes from the mill at Wexley Bridge. So, these sacks were never ours to begin with.”

Rose looked up at the solicitor.

“30 sacks claimed as spoiled. 30 replacement sacks bought from Pell at £1 10 shillings each. £45 for flour we never lost.”

Mr. Fenwick wrote it down. The Duke looked at his cook.

“Mrs. Dunning, you walked 6 miles into town with a sack of sawdust on your back.”

“I came in on the carrier’s cart, Your Grace. I’m not a fool. But I’d have walked it.”

Then she reached out and squeezed Rose’s good wrist.

“You were right about the eggs, too,” she muttered. “Last year, I never said so. I’m saying so now.”

“Thank you, Mrs. Dunning.”

“Don’t thank me. Just come home when this is done. The new girl they’ve sent me can’t count past 12.”

That evening, Rose stayed late in the chambers to copy the flour figures by lamplight, and the Duke waited by the cold fireplace to see her safely back to the Bell.