“Thank you for telling me plainly,” said Rose. “That is more than the person who wrote this did.”

An hour later, a second letter came. It was from Mrs. Hatherly, a widow in the town of Ledbury, who’d offered Rose a post as her housekeeper a fortnight before. It was to have been Rose’s new start. The letter was very short. “I have received information concerning your character, which I cannot in conscience ignore. I must withdraw my offer.” Folded inside was the scrap of the anonymous note Mrs. Hatherly had received.

Returned so that Rose might know what was said of her. The red wax seal was still attached. Rose looked at the details as she always did. The seal showed a sheaf of wheat inside a ring.

The mark of the Hallamere estate office. And at the top right of the ring, a small piece was missing. A chip. Like a bite taken out of a biscuit.

She had seen that chipped seal a hundred times. On every order Silas Garrow ever signed. She walked across the square to Mr. Fenwick’s chambers, where the Duke was already waiting. And laid the letters on the table without a word.

He read them. She watched the color leave his face. And then come back. Darker.

“Ledbury?” he said. “You had a post.”

“I had a post. And the Bell has given me one week.”

“Let me write to Mrs. Hatherly,” he said, “today, under my own seal. Let me write to every house in this county and tell them I will receive no one who repeats this filth. I can end it by tomorrow night, Rose. You know I can.”

Rose opened her folder. She took out a thick sheaf of papers tied with plain tape. Her own record of three years at Hallamere.

Every winter account. Every relief list. She laid it on the table.

“I did not keep honest books for three years,” she said quietly, “only to hide behind a duke’s signature the first time my name is questioned.”

He stopped.

“If you write that letter every house will say, ‘Of course he defends her.’ And they will believe the note more, not less. I will be the woman the duke protected for the rest of my life. I do not want to be protected, Thomas. I want to be believed.”

The duke looked at her for a long time. Then he sat down.

“Your fourth condition,” he said.

“My fourth condition.”

“I said it would be the hardest. I did not know how hard.”

He let out a long breath.

“Tell me what I may do instead.”

“Write one plain letter as any honest employer would. My dates of service and my duties. Nothing more. And I will write the rest myself.”

So she wrote it in her own steady hand. She did not plead. She stated that the note was false and offered her accounts to any examination Mrs. Hatherly chose. She enclosed one winter’s relief ledger.

40 households. Every sack of flour, every hundredweight of coal, balanced to the last farthing. Then she wrote one more letter to Mrs. Abney at the North Cottages asking whether she would say in her own words what had happened three winters ago. When she looked up the duke was watching her.

“I was remembering Lady Fairley’s spoons,” he said.

Rose groaned.

“Not the spoons.”

“The spoons,” he told Mr. Fenwick. “Two summers ago, Lady Fairley accused our youngest housemaid, a girl of 15, of stealing a silver spoon and demanded she be dismissed. Miss Calder walked in with the plate book. 47 spoons laid out. 47 counted back. And then she said… What did you say, Rose?”