She knew them at once. She had seen the same volumes on Sarah’s kitchen table only the week before, sent down from London with the printer’s compliments. He looked up and saw her and got to his feet so fast that he nearly dropped the book.

“Miss Penham. I did not hear the carriage.”

Then before she could say a word, he held it up like a boy with a prize.

“It came this morning. I have not stopped. I have not eaten. I am in the third volume. And I have to tell you, I promised I would tell you. I was entirely wrong about her. Entirely. I have never been so wrong about anything in my life.”

Sophia stood just inside the door with her bonnet strings in her hands. She had come to say something and she had practiced it all the way across the plain. Now the words had gone clean out of her head.

“Wrong how?”

She heard herself ask.

“She was watching. You said so. And you were right. And I did not understand you. All through the first book and all through this one, she’s been seeing what nobody else saw. And now her sister is to be married to the wrong man. And the whole family is in a flutter. Nobody knows what to do. And Mary stands up.”

He found the place with his finger. His voice changed as he began to read. It went quiet and careful, the way a man’s voice goes when he’s reading something he loves aloud for the first time.

“You all believe that because I do not speak, I do not see. I have seen everything. I have seen it for years.”

He stopped there and looked up at her and his eyes were shining.

“There, you see, that is the whole of it. I owe her an apology. I owe the author an apology. I would write and tell her so if I had the least idea who she was.”

And Sophia, standing in the doorway with her heart in her mouth, said the next line aloud before she could stop herself. She said it quietly, word for word, exactly as she had written it on a cold night in March, with the candle burning down.

“I have only been waiting until I could say it kindly.”

Walter looked down at the page. She watched him find the line. She watched him read it once and then again and then lift his head very slowly.

“How do you know that?”

She had meant to say it gently. She had meant to sit down first and explain and begin at the beginning. Instead, she let go of her bonnet strings and said it the way Mary Marlo would have said it, simply because there was no kinder way.

“Because I wrote it, Walter.”

She had never once said his name before. It fell into the quiet of the library like a stone into a well, and they both heard it land. He did not move. One second. 2.

3. The fire settled in the grate. Outside the long window, a rook went across the gray sky and the wind moved the tops of the beeches. Walter stood with the open book in his hands and looked at her as if she had walked into the room through the wall.

“All of them?” he said at last.

“All of them. The Marlo sisters and the one between. And this. I wrote the first one sitting on the floor of the room under our roof because it was the only place in the house where I could see the sky.”

She swallowed.

“I wrote the page about the chimney sweep long before your brother died. I did not know. I did not know until you told me in the green room that anyone had read it in the dark.”

He put the book down on the table very carefully as if it might break. Then he walked to the window and stood with his back to her, and she saw his hand come up and cover his eyes. She could see him going back over it all. The dinner and the girl in the corner who thought Mary Marlo was watching.