It seemed to her a very sensible thing for a stone to do. Old Moore itself was a long, low house of pale stone in a fold of the down with beech woods behind it and a park in front where the deer were already turning red for the autumn. Inside it was beautiful and rather empty like a church on a weekday. There were not many guests. There was a neighbor or two and the vicar and his wife and the Duke’s cousin, Mrs. Lacy, who had kept house for him since his brother died.

Juliana Lacy was a widow of perhaps 30 and very handsome. She was dressed in dark blue silk with a lace scarf about her shoulders, and she had beautiful hands, which she was careful to use. She was to be married herself at Christmas to an older gentleman of good fortune who lived near Marlborough, and she wore his ring on the outside of her glove. She greeted Sophia with great warmth and looked her up and down in a single glance, from her bonnet to her shoes. Sophia saw her decide in that glance that there was nothing there worth worrying about.

It was a look she had seen many times. She was rather fond of it. It meant she would be left alone. At dinner, she sat at the Duke’s right hand and said almost nothing and listened to everything. She learned that the vicar’s wife was afraid of her husband, and the vicar did not know it.

She learned that the neighbor on her left had sold a horse he should not have sold. She learned that Mrs. Lacy touched her ring whenever anyone mentioned money. And she learned that the Duke ate very little and drank less and listened to his guests with a kind of patient attention, as if he were waiting for somebody to say something that mattered. It was the Vicar’s wife who brought up the novels.

Had anyone read the Marlo sisters? Everyone in London was reading it, and there was to be a new one at Michaelmas. And was it true that it had been written by a duchess? Sophia went on eating her soup.

“I hope not,” Mrs. Lacy said with a little laugh. “I tried the first volume and could not finish it. A great deal of people sitting in parlor and nothing whatever happening and a silly young woman in the corner of every chapter who never says a word. I cannot think what London sees in it.”

“London sees itself,” the Duke said.

It was the first thing he had said in 10 minutes and the whole table turned to look at him. He set down his glass.

“That is what the author does. She looks at a room full of ordinary people and she sees what each of them is afraid of. And then she is kind to them anyway. I have never read anything like it.”

He seemed to hear himself then and he stopped. A faint color came into his face.

“Forgive me. I’ve read it four times. It makes me tedious.”

Sophia kept her eyes on her plate. Her heart was beating so hard that she was afraid it would show at the neck of her gown.

“Four times?”

She had not known that anybody read anything four times except the Bible and the racing news.

“And the silent girl in the corner,” Mrs. Lacy said, smiling at him, “do you defend her too, Walter?”

“No,” he said, and smiled a little himself. “No, I confess Mary Marlo defeats me. She is the only thing in the book I would change. She sits there through three volumes and I cannot make out why the author keeps her.”

He turned to Sophia courteously as a host turns to a guest who has been left out.

“Have you read it, Miss Penham?”

“Yes, Your Grace.”

Her voice came out perfectly level. She was rather proud of it.

“And what did you make of Mary Marlo?”

She thought about it. She thought about it so long that Mrs. Lacy’s mouth began to curve and the neighbor on her left began to look at his plate. Then she said: