“I thought she was watching.”

“Watching what?”

“Everyone,” said Sophia. “Somebody has to.”

There was a small pause. The Duke looked at her for a moment with an expression she could not read. Then the vicar’s wife began to talk about the price of coal, and the moment was gone. Later in the drawing room, while the gentlemen were still at their wine, Sophia went to find her shawl, which she had left in the hall.

The door of a little side parlor stood open, and as she passed it, she heard Mrs. Lacy’s voice low and amused, and then the Duke’s answering. She had not meant to listen. But she had spent her whole life not meaning to listen, and she had never once managed to stop.

“She has not said 20 words all evening. Walter, are you sure you know what you’re doing?”

“Quite sure.”

His voice was tired and patient.

“I do not want a wife who will fill the house with noise. I want one who will not mind a husband who spends his evenings in the library. Miss Penham is quiet. She is restful. She will not trouble me.”

A pause.

“I expect nothing more from it than that, Juliana. And I expect she expects nothing more from me.”

Sophia found her shawl. She put it around her shoulders and went back into the drawing room and sat down in the corner by the fire where she could see the whole room. Nobody noticed her come in.

She sat with her hands folded in her lap, and thought quite steadily that she had been called worse things than restful, and by people who had read a great deal less. It did not hurt very much. It only made her feel, for a little while, extremely lonely.

Walter did not go to bed after the carriages had gone. He went to the library as he always did and lit the lamp on the table by the long window. Then he took down the first volume of the Marlo sisters from the shelf where it stood beside his brother’s old Latin books. The spine was cracked in three places. He did not open it at once.

He sat with it on his knee and looked at the dark glass where his own face looked back at him over the lamp and he thought about the quiet girl in the rose pink gown. Her words came back to him. “I thought she was watching.” It was a strange thing for a dull girl to say. It was a stranger thing that it should have stayed with him all evening through the port and the coal prices and Juliana’s little jokes. He had been rude, he thought, to talk so much about the book in front of her.

He had seen her keep her eyes on her plate. She had probably been embarrassed for him. He did not blame her. He was a little embarrassed for himself. He had not meant to say anything at all.

But there were very few things in the world he cared about, and that book was one of them. He had found it the winter his brother died. Old Moore had been so silent then that he could hear the clocks in rooms three doors away. He had taken to sitting up in this chair with whatever came to hand. And one night what came to hand was a novel in three volumes that the vicar’s wife had left behind.

He had begun it out of politeness. He had finished it at 5:00 in the morning with the lamp guttering and the snow coming down outside, and he had not felt alone for the first time in a month. There was a scene in the second volume that he could have said by heart. A little sweep, no more than six, came down a chimney into the Marlos’ parlor, black from head to foot and coughing, and the whole family stood about him in a fluster. The eldest sister fetched a cloth.

The mother called for the housekeeper, and Mary Marlo, the silent one, went quietly to the table and gave the child her own bread. She sat down on the hearth beside him while he ate it and asked him his name. It was the only time in the whole book that she spoke first. Walter had read that page a dozen times. He had gone up to London in the spring and found out how many children went up chimneys every year and how many of them died there.