Her father stood just inside the door with his hat in both hands. He was a big, square man, gone gray since she had last seen him in daylight. He did not look at her. He looked at the turkey carpet as if it might be undermined. The duke stood behind Cecily’s chair.
He did not speak. She had asked him not to, and he had agreed.
“We are here for His Grace’s final answer,” said Mr. Culpepper. “Mrs. Treloar is ready to swear to her stepdaughter’s character. And my aunt’s state of mind that week is, I think, beyond dispute.”
“It is,” said Cecily.
She laid the scrap of pasteboard on the table.
“You played piquet with her on the 11th of March, Mr. Culpepper. You lost 11 guineas. She made you sign for it because she never trusted you with a debt. That is your hand, I think.”
Mr. Culpepper looked at the card. His attorney looked at the card.
“And this,” said Cecily, opening the green bank book, “is your draft for 11 guineas paid in the next morning. You may tell the court in Doctors’ Commons that your aunt was out of her senses that week. You will have to tell them she beat you at piquet out of her senses. I think they will laugh, sir. I very nearly did.”
The library was utterly silent. Mr. Culpepper’s face did a thing Cecily had never seen a face do. It seemed to slide slowly from the top down like wet plaster off a wall. His attorney cleared his throat and then, wisely, did not.
“Whatever the courts say,” said Loveday Treloar quite loudly, “her own father would not have her in the house.”
Cecily turned in her chair. She did not look at her stepmother. She looked at her father.
“I wrote to you, Father,” she said, “every quarter for six years.”
She put the bundle of letters on the table, still in its tape.
“They came back to me marked ‘Refused.’ The post comes to Porthkellis at eleven. Where were you at eleven, Father?”
Josiah Treloar lifted his head. He looked at the bundle. He looked at the calling card beside it in his wife’s cramped brown hand. Then, very slowly, he looked at his wife.
“Below,” he said.
It was the first word he had spoken.
“I am always below at eleven.”
“And there is my mother’s settlement,” said Cecily.
She laid Mr. Penberthy’s letter beside the others.
“£40 a year paid every Lady Day into your account at Truro for my sole use. £240 in six years. I received £48 of it, with a letter each time telling me how much was being done for me.”
Loveday Treloar’s handsome face had gone the color of tallow. She opened her mouth, found the whole room looking at her, and shut it again. Cecily could have ruined her. It would have taken one more sentence. A trust diverted, a husband deceived, a stepdaughter robbed, and an attorney from Bodmin sitting there with his ears open.