He touched his hat and walked away up the hill. Three days later, the trouble came up from the cove. Cecily had gone down to buy mackerel because Mrs. Kitto did not trust the boy to choose them. The boats lay drawn up on the shingle with their catches in silver heaps. 20 fishermen stood in a knot by the capstan. In the middle of them stood the duke, his agent, and a thin man in a good coat with a tally board under his arm.

“Mr. Roe buys the catch, Your Grace,” the agent was saying.

“He counts us short,” said a broad grey fisherman.

“I count a hundred as a hundred,” said Mr. Roe. “Six score and twelve, the warp included, as every buyer in the West Country counts it.”

Cecily stopped walking.

“Not in this cove,” she said.

20 heads turned. The agent looked at her as he might have looked at a gull that had spoken. She knew what the old fishermen expected. They expected the gentry to laugh at the companion from the newspapers.

“In every cove from here to the Lizard, a hundred of mackerel is the long hundred,” she said. “Six score—120 fish, not 132. My grandfather sold fish off the beach at Porthkellis for 40 years, and my mother counted them for him.”

“And who might you be?” said Mr. Roe.

“Somebody who can read a tally board,” said Cecily. “May I?”

The duke made a small movement of his hand. Mr. Roe slowly gave her the board. The figures were neat. Neat figures were often the dishonest kind.

“Since Lady Day, you have taken 31,680 fish from these boats,” she said. “Counted at six score, that is 264 hundreds. Counted at your 132, it is 240. You have paid for 240 at 18 shillings. So these men are owed for 24 hundreds of mackerel they have already given you. £21 and 12 shillings since Lady Day.”

She handed back the board.

“I have not counted last year,” she said. “I expect the agent can.”

The beach was silent except for the gulls. Then the broad grey fisherman took off his cap. One by one down the whole knot of them, the others did the same. He looked at Cecily.

“Thank you, Miss Treloar,” he said.

“Mrs. Kitto’s mackerel are in the second boat,” said Cecily. “The first boat’s are soft.”

She walked back up the cliff with six mackerel on a string and her heart going like a drum. Ambrose Loxley stood on the shingle until the last boat was hauled. He had sent Mr. Roe home with a promise of the magistrates that had turned the man the colour of his own mackerel. He was watching a figure in a grey cloak climb the cliff path with a string of fish swinging from one hand. He had been warned about her in Bath.

“Designing,” Culpepper had said. “A mercenary little thing with a quick tongue.”

His great aunt had written something else in a letter he had never answered.

“My companion counts better than my banker and lies worse than a dog.”