“Do you wish me to pay him?” said the Duke.
She stared at him. He was asking her. He was waiting for her to say.
“No,” said Cecily. “If you pay him, I am a thief for the rest of my life, and a bought one. I would rather be poor and right, Your Grace. I have had a great deal of practice at it.”
Something moved in his face and was gone.
“Miss Treloar declines,” he said.
“Then I shall see you both in Doctors’ Commons,” said Mr. Culpepper. “I shall call again in six days with my attorney, and I shall bring the stepmother and the father too.”
“You may bring the whole family,” said the Duke. “I will have the fires lit.”
When he had gone, Cecily turned to the window.
“He will win,” she said. “My stepmother will swear to anything, and my father believes it.”
“Then we must find something your father cannot help believing,” said the Duke.
They searched for four days. Lady Ashby’s three boxes stood open in the dower house parlor and Cecily went through every paper twice. 412 letters about feet. The Duke came down every afternoon and sat by the fire and read what she passed him and said almost nothing. Mrs. Kitto brought them tea and did not lock the sugar away. On the third afternoon, Cecily read him a letter in which Lady Ashby described her chiropodist as a Jacobin.
The Duke laughed. It was a short, rusty, startled sound as if he had found it in a coat pocket. In the passage, Mrs. Kitto set down the tray with a bang.
“Well,” she said to nobody. “There’s a thing I haven’t heard since before the old Duchess died.”
On the fourth night, Cecily sat up alone with one candle. She had nothing. Everyone who had seen the old woman that week had seen her in bed and a woman in bed could be called anything. She reached for the book of sermons for something to do with her hands, and the scrap of pasteboard fell out into her lap. She had used it as a marker for two months.
She had never once looked at it. It was a piquet score. Lady Ashby kept her scores on the backs of old visiting cards. At the foot of this one, in a thick, florid hand, someone had written a line and initialed it.
“Owed to Lady Ashby, 11 guineas, 11th March, HC.”
Cecily sat very still. The 11th of March, the day of the codicil. The day Mr. Horatio Culpepper swore his aunt had lain out of her senses in a darkened room. On that day, his aunt had beaten him at piquet, taken 11 guineas off him, and made him sign for it. She went to the third box, Lady Ashby’s bank book, bound in green, kept in her own crabbed hand.
“12th March, received of H. Culpepper by draft on his banker, 11 guineas.”
Cecily put on her cloak, went up the cliff walk in her slippers, and knocked on the library door herself. Six days later, the library smelled of beeswax, wet umbrellas, and a great deal of confidence. Most of it was Mr. Culpepper’s. He had brought his attorney, a thin man from Bodmin who kept clearing his throat. He had brought Loveday Treloar in her good gray cloth and her mourning brooch, and he had brought Captain Josiah Treloar.