“£30 is too little.”

“It is what Lady Ashby paid me.”

“Lady Ashby was a miser.”

“She was,” Cecily agreed. “She was also honest about it.”

There was a pause.

“£30,” he said. “And you will sit by the fire. You took the chair nearest the window,” he said. “It is the coldest chair in Cornwall. I would like it understood that the fire is also part of the arrangement.”

Neither of them pretended it was anything but an arrangement. It was the most comfortable conversation she had held in a month. At the door he stopped.

“Your father,” he said, “did he ever have your letters?”

“They came back to me, Your Grace. Every one by way of the post office, marked ‘Refused.’ Eleven pence a letter from Bath to Truro, and he would not pay it. I stopped writing in the fourth year.”

The duke said nothing. He looked at her a moment longer than courtesy required. Then he went out into the dark. She unpacked that night by candlelight. Under her two good gowns lay the bundle of letters tied with tape.

Every one marked refused in a cramped brown hand. Under the letters lay a book of sermons Lady Ashby had never once opened. A scrap of pasteboard marked her place in it as it had for two months. She did not look at it. She put the book on the shelf and blew out the candle.

On Sunday the church of St. Carro smelled of damp hassocks, cold stone, and opinions. Bonnets turned as she walked up the aisle behind Mrs. Kitto. Somebody whispered,

“Bath.”

Somebody else whispered,

“The Dower House.”

And that was worse. After the service in the porch Lady Trembath was waiting. She was the wife of Sir Humphrey Trembath, baronet, and she wore lilac silk and a smile that had been sharpened on the curate. Four ladies stood behind her like a choir.

“Miss Treloar,” she said, “one hears you are lodged at the Dower House.”

“I am, ma’am.”

“How very convenient for His Grace. A bachelor of his habits must find a companion so very useful about the place. And of course we all know what became of the last woman he took into that house?”

The porch went quiet.

“I don’t,” said Cecily. “Were you there?”

Lady Trembath opened her mouth. Nothing came out of it.

“I am cataloging his late great-aunt’s papers, Lady Trembath,” Cecily went on. “There are 412 letters in them about her feet. If His Grace finds that convenient, he has a stronger stomach than I have.”

Nobody laughed. Nobody breathed. Four bonnets stared very hard at the gravestones.

“The wind is going round to the west, ma’am,” said Cecily. “You will want to hold on to your hat.”

Only at the lychgate did she understand what she had done. She had defended him. She had defended a man she believed was keeping her under lock and key to a porch full of strangers for no reason she could name. Then she saw him under the yew by the gate where he must have heard every word. His face told her nothing.