But it was the only place in the world where she had ever known exactly what to do. Without it, there was no dyeing. Without dyeing, there was no money for the cottage or the medicine, or Thea’s shoes. It was as plain as that.

She was still standing there with her sleeves rolled to the elbow and her arms red to the wrist when a shadow fell across the doorway. She thought it was the steward come back. She turned. It was the Duke.

He had walked down from the top of the valley by the path through the alders and he had his coat over his shoulder because of the heat. His shirt was open at the throat. He looked as if he had not slept much. He stopped on the threshold and for a moment neither of them said anything and the stream went on talking to itself outside.

“Miss Winton.”

He did not come in.

“I have seen the paper. I came to say that I have done you a great wrong. It was my wager and my foolishness, and you have had to pay for it. I know what is being said. I know that your trade has suffered. There is only one honorable thing I can offer you and I am offering it.”

He said the rest very formally as though he had rehearsed it on the walk down and was afraid of losing his place.

“I am asking you to do me the honor of becoming my wife.”

Alma looked at him. She looked at him for long enough that he began very slightly to color. She had imagined many things in the four days since the ball, lying awake at night. She had not imagined this. She found that she was not glad. She was something else, something cold and clear that sat in her chest like a stone in a stream.

“No,” she said. “Thank you, Your Grace. But no.”

He was silent. Then he said carefully:

“May I ask why?”

She turned away from him and put her hands on the rim of the madder tub because she needed something to hold.

“Because you are not asking me,” she said. “You are paying your wager. You are settling a quarrel with your friends in London and a quarrel with your mother here, and I happen to be standing in the middle of both. If I married you now, everybody in this county would know that the paper was right: that I knew about the wager, that I dyed myself a red gown to catch a duke and caught him.”

She turned back.

“They say in the harbor that a yard of red wool bought me a husband. I will not let them be right.”

“Does it matter?” he said slowly. “Why it is done if it mends the harm?”

“It matters to me. I will not be married because I wore the wrong color to a ball.”

Then, because he looked so tired, and because she was honest, she told him about the steward, that his mother wanted the shed down, and that she had until the hay was in. She watched his face while she spoke, and saw that he had not known. Something went hard behind his eyes. He would speak to his mother, he told her that very afternoon.