“I asked you where you were tonight,” she said. “You told me you were helping your brother.”
“I can explain.”
“Then start there.”
Ellie stayed close to her mother. Sam’s eyes moved from Caleb to Beth, who stood rigid beside the counter. Suddenly Beth seemed to understand that the people she had dismissed as Caleb’s former life were not abstractions. They were standing in her kitchen.
“Dad,” Sam said, “did you tell Mom you were leaving?”
Caleb hesitated. “It’s complicated.”
“You’ve been saying that since spring.”
Beth looked at him sharply. “You said you’d already separated.”
Diane closed her eyes for a moment. “We still live in the same house. He asked me to book our anniversary dinner last week.”
Caleb held out both hands. “Everybody needs to calm down.”
It was then that Ellie noticed the necklace around Beth’s throat: an oval gold locket with a tiny dent near the hinge. Her face changed so suddenly that I thought she might be ill.
“Mom,” Ellie whispered. “Look at her necklace.”
Diane raised her eyes. She took one step toward Beth, then stopped without touching her.
“Where did you get that?” she asked.
Beth touched the locket. “Caleb gave it to me.”
“When?”
“Two months ago. He said it belonged to his grandmother.”
Diane looked at her husband. The color had gone from his face.
“That was my mother’s,” she said. “You told me the jeweler lost it.”
Caleb reached toward the necklace, but Ellie stepped between them.
“Don’t touch it, Dad. Not until we see what’s inside.”
—
Beth carefully unclasped the chain with trembling fingers. I had seen her wear it to dinner, the store, and neighborhood barbecues. She had once asked whether I liked it. I had said it was pretty without knowing whose history hung at her throat.
She placed the locket on a folded dish towel. Ellie opened it carefully, using the tip of a fingernail. Inside were two tiny photographs. In one, a young woman stood in front of a farmhouse. In the other, a little girl with dark curls clung to that woman’s skirt.
“That’s Grandma Ruth,” Ellie said. “And that’s Mom when she was six.”
Diane sat down in my kitchen chair. “She wore that necklace every day. When she died, she left it to me. The clasp broke last winter, and Caleb offered to take it for repair.”
“I did take it,” he said. “I meant to replace it.”
“You told me the repair shop misplaced it.”
“I was going to find another one.”
Ellie stared at him. “You can’t replace those photographs.”
Beth stepped back from the counter. “You told me your grandmother wanted you to give it to someone special.”