“Beth, not now.”

“You said she gave it to you before she died.”

His silence told her he had never intended to explain.

I was furious with Beth for months of lies, but she clearly had not known the necklace belonged to Diane. She had been deceived about that, even while deceiving me.

Diane put the locket down beside the photographs. “I wasn’t imagining it,” she murmured.

Sam frowned. “What do you mean?”

“When it disappeared, your father said I must have given it to someone and forgotten. Ellie and I looked through every drawer. I thought grief was making my memory unreliable.”

Caleb looked toward the door. “We’re not discussing this in somebody else’s house.”

Diane spoke without raising her voice. “You made me doubt myself for eight weeks over my mother’s last gift. Where would you prefer we discuss that?”

Then Sam took out his phone. “Mom, there’s something else he told us you were forgetting.”

—

Sam’s phone showed a message Caleb had sent in the family group chat six weeks earlier. Diane came for answers, not revenge, and wanted Caleb to stop defining what everyone else believed. It said Diane was struggling with stress, forgetting appointments, and becoming suspicious of ordinary things. He asked the children to be patient with her and not repeat upsetting details that might make her anxious.

“I believed you,” Sam told him. “When Mom asked me if you were seeing someone, I said she was imagining things.”

Diane stared at the message. “You said that about me?”

Caleb rubbed his forehead. “I was trying to keep the peace.”

“You were trying to keep us from asking questions,” Ellie said.

Diane first contacted me after a friend spotted Caleb on our street. Her message was cautious. I was embarrassed by how many unexplained evenings Beth had spent away, but I finally called Diane.

We compared dates, not rumors. On nights Caleb claimed to be helping his brother, Beth said she was attending late training sessions. Diane showed me a text from Caleb promising he was bringing home takeout for her. That same evening, Beth sent me a photograph of a restaurant dessert and said she was eating with coworkers.

Diane had invited the children herself. They chose to come because Caleb had used them to silence their mother.

Now Ellie held the message in front of her father. “You made us think Mom was losing her memory.”

“That’s not what I meant.”

“It’s what you wrote.”

Beth folded her arms, but the confidence had gone from her voice. “You told me Diane knew the marriage was over.”

“It was over in everything but paperwork,” Caleb said.

Diane looked at him for a long time. “You asked me to pick the restaurant for our anniversary. You helped Ellie choose the flowers.”