“We talked about the dates. We both needed to know what was true.”
“You could have come to me.”
“I did. Twice. You told me I was imagining things and that I should find a hobby.”
She remembered. I could see it on her face.
When I asked about late evenings, Beth blamed work. When I mentioned Caleb’s truck, she laughed. Later, she invited him inside while I visited my granddaughter.
Diane stood. “We’re leaving,” she told the children. “No one needs to settle anything here tonight.”
Caleb started toward her. “You can’t walk away without letting me explain.”
“You can write down what happened. You can tell me the truth tomorrow. I don’t have to stand here while you work out which story sounds best.”
Ellie looked at Beth one last time, then at her father. “I don’t want you at my apartment tonight. Don’t call me to explain why Mom is confused. I know what I saw.”
Sam said he would drive his mother home. Caleb told him that people were taking this too far.
“You made us doubt her,” Sam replied. “That’s the part you still won’t talk about.”
They left quietly. Caleb lingered at my doorway; I thought he might apologize.
Instead, he looked at me and said, “You enjoyed that.”
“No,” I answered. “But I wasn’t going to keep your secret for you.”
He went out without another word.
When the door closed, Beth asked me whether I had told my daughter, Megan, about the affair. I shook my head.
“Then don’t,” she said. “Please. She’s always thought I was part of her family.”
I looked at the mug Caleb had used. “You should have remembered that before tonight.”
—
I barely slept in the guest room. I had not stopped loving every memory simply because I could no longer trust her. The furnace started and stopped while I remembered Beth leaving a lamp on for me after late shifts. She had cared for Megan and my granddaughter. Betrayal could not erase those years.
In the morning, Beth said Caleb made her feel young again. She accused us of discussing bills instead of dreams. There was truth there: after knee surgery, I withdrew into work.
“I should have listened better,” I told her. “You should have told me you were unhappy instead of making another man part of our marriage.”
Beth cried. “I thought you didn’t care anymore.”
“I cared enough to ask. You made me feel foolish for noticing.”
She wanted us to keep everything quiet until she decided whether she wanted to stay. I told her I would not post photographs, contact her employer, or tell neighbors private details. But I would speak honestly with the people whose lives our separation would affect. I would not lie to Megan or let Beth use our family as cover again.