Ellie swallowed hard. “Dad, you asked me to write your toast.”

Caleb said nothing.

“There’s a line in that toast,” Ellie continued, “about how you’ve never given Mom reason to doubt you. Were you planning to stand up and say that?”

—

Ellie had spent two weeks preparing Caleb’s anniversary toast. She ordered flowers, booked a restaurant, and found an old photograph of her parents. Now Caleb looked at her as though he expected rescue.

“You knew what I was planning,” he said. “You knew I wanted the dinner to be special.”

“I thought it was special because you loved Mom,” Ellie answered.

Sam asked whether there was another reason for the celebration. Caleb said there wasn’t. But Beth suddenly spoke.

“He told me he was going to announce the separation after the dinner. He said he didn’t want to spoil the anniversary for the children.”

Diane looked almost amused by the cruelty of that explanation. “Our children are twenty-nine and twenty-five. They are not toddlers who need a birthday cake before they hear the truth.”

“Beth,” Caleb warned.

She turned on him. “You told me your wife had agreed to the separation. You said you were only going home to pick up clothes.”

“I said we were moving in that direction.”

“No. You said she knew.”

Listening gave me no satisfaction. Beth and I had spent seventeen years helping neighbors, raising a family, and building a home. Those years were real. So was this betrayal.

Diane looked at the locket on the dish towel. She did not take it immediately. “Ellie, could you put it somewhere safe?”

Ellie wrapped it in a clean napkin and slipped it into her coat pocket. “We’ll take it to the jeweler together,” she said.

Caleb gave a short laugh. “So now I’m being treated like a thief?”

“I’m treating you like the man who knew exactly whose necklace it was,” Diane replied.

Beth took one deep, reluctant breath. “I never would have worn it if I’d known.”

“I believe you didn’t know the necklace,” Diane said. “I don’t believe you didn’t know he was married.”

Beth opened her mouth, then stopped. Her silence confirmed what I had already learned from the messages.

Ellie slowly looked at me and asked a question no one else had been willing to ask: “Frank, how long have you known?”

—

“Long enough to wish I were wrong,” I told Ellie. “Not long enough to get used to it.”

I explained that Diane contacted me three weeks earlier. Our records showed at least seven months of meetings, and neither of them had confessed. I kept the private messages to myself; the dates disproved their stories.

Beth stared at me. “You spent three weeks talking to his wife?”