“Because you are not asking me,” she said. “You are paying your wager. You are settling a quarrel with your friends in London and a quarrel with your mother here, and I happen to be standing in the middle of both. If I married you now, everybody in this county would know that the paper was right: that I knew about the wager, that I dyed myself a red gown to catch a duke and caught him.”
She turned back.
“They say in the harbor that a yard of red wool bought me a husband. I will not let them be right.”
“Does it matter?” he said slowly. “Why it is done if it mends the harm?”
“It matters to me. I will not be married because I wore the wrong color to a ball.”
Then, because he looked so tired, and because she was honest, she told him about the steward, that his mother wanted the shed down, and that she had until the hay was in. She watched his face while she spoke, and saw that he had not known. Something went hard behind his eyes. He would speak to his mother, he told her that very afternoon.
“Please don’t,” Alma said. “If you quarrel with her over me, you only prove the paper right a second time. The valley is hers. She may do as she likes with it.”
She wiped her hands on her apron, which did no good at all.
“I am not asking you for anything, Your Grace. I never was. That is the whole of it.”
He looked at her hands and then at the vat beside her, where the red bath steamed gently in the heat.
“What is that color?” he asked.
It was so unexpected that she answered without thinking.
“Madder? It’s a root. You dig it up and dry it and grind it and then it makes this.”
“The gown you wore. Was it this?”
She nodded.
“I have never seen anything that color in my life.”
There was no flattery in it. He spoke as plainly as a man telling the hour. Then he put his coat back over his shoulder. At the door he stopped.
“If I came back, would you let me?”
It was his mother’s valley, Alma told him.
“That isn’t what I asked.”
A wood pigeon was calling somewhere up in the alders. The same five notes over and over.
“If you ever ask me again,” Alma said at last, “ask me for my own sake, not for your honor. Then I will listen. Until then, you may come back if you like. I cannot stop you.”
He bowed and went away up the path, and she stood watching until the alders closed behind him. He came back 2 days later, but not to the shed. Alma was hanging a line of blue wool in the sun when she heard the haymakers laughing in the big meadow across the stream, and she looked up to see why. The tall man in shirt sleeves was standing on the wagon with a pitchfork, taking the hay as the men threw it up. He was building the load the way it should be built, square at the corners and solid in the middle, so that it would not shift on the road.
His chestnut hair was full of haydust. His face was red with the sun. The men were laughing because they did not know what else to do with a duke on a haywagon, and the Duke did not seem to mind them laughing at all. She watched for longer than she meant to. He was good at it.