He had not laughed like that since. Sophonisba stood on the cliff path above the valley and watched the Duke of Rookhope laughing on a bench beside the girl from the dye shed with her red hands. Then she went on down the hill to do her errand, and she told nobody what she had seen. It was that same evening, when the light had begun at last to go gold and long across the meadows, that he told Alma about his sister. She had not asked.

She had only said without thinking that she did not understand why his mother hated the color red so much when it was only a root. For a long while he gave no answer. He turned a lump of chalk over and over in his stained fingers, and she began to be sorry she had spoken. Then he said:

“There was a portrait. There still is. It hangs at the end of the long gallery with its face to the wall. It is of my sister. Her name is Mariel. Nobody in that house has said her name aloud for 12 years.”

He told it plainly, the way he had built the hay load. His sister had been four years older than he was, quick and loud and clever, and she had always been in trouble. On the night of her first ball at Blackwind, she had walked in at the door of the ballroom in a gown of red silk. She had bought it with her own pin money and hidden it in her room for a month.

Their mother had wanted her in white. There had been a terrible quarrel, and Mariel had danced all night in the red anyway, and their father had laughed and said she looked splendid. He had the portrait painted that same summer in that gown.

“She looked like a flame,” he said. “I thought she was the most remarkable person I had ever seen.”

When she was 3 and 20, his sister had fallen in love with a ship’s master from Lyme, a good, steady, sensible man with no fortune and no family that anybody had heard of. Their mother had forbidden it. Their father, by then, was ill and did what their mother said. So Mariel had left. She had married the ship’s master in the church at Lyme, and their mother had told her that if she went, she need not write, and she need not come back.

“And she did not,” Orlando said. “She did as she was told, for once in her life. And the next morning, my mother had the portrait turned to the wall.”

He threw the chalk into the stream.

“I was 19. I was at home. I could have written to her. I could have ridden to Lyme. It is half a day on a good horse and I never did.”

Alma said nothing. He went on looking at the water.

“I told myself it was obedience, that my mother was grieving, that my father was dying, that it was not my place. Then my father died and the house was mine. And I still did not go. Each year it got harder. You begin to think that if you have waited this long, it must be because there was a reason. And then you cannot remember what the reason was.”

He stopped. When he spoke again, his voice was very low.

“I cannot remember her voice, and I try. I know she laughed a great deal. I cannot hear it.”

The light lay gold along the tops of the alders. Somewhere up in the hay meadow, a man was singing as he walked home, the words too far off to hear. Alma looked at the Duke sitting beside her on the bench with his red hands hanging between his knees and his head down. She had thought him proud at the ball. She had thought him careless, writing wagers in books.