“If you will permit me, madam,” he said, quite low. His face was very still. “I think I should prefer to work it myself.”
She looked at him. Then she held out the chalk.
He took it. He did not thank her. He turned to the board and wrote out the Halcyon’s observation from the journal, the distance, the altitudes, the time, in his large and beautiful hand. And then, slowly, in front of the Commissioners and a hundred and fifty people, he began to work the lunar by the rigorous method in Maskelyne.
It took him twenty-five minutes. Nobody spoke. Judith stood beside the board with her hands clasped, and watched the figures go down, and found herself, absurdly, wishing him well: willing him past the places where a tired man might slip, as she had once willed her father down a column. He did not slip. He was, whatever else he was, a very good mathematician. At the foot of the work he wrote the true distance, and from the Almanac the Greenwich time, and from the Greenwich time the Halcyon’s longitude, and stood back.
Then he took up his own proof, and found the page, and worked it again by his own method: first correction, second correction, third.
He looked out the third correction, and wrote it down. A plus sign. Forty-one miles from the bank.
His hand stopped on the board.
For a long moment he stood looking at the two results: twenty-seven miles and forty-one. Then, very deliberately, he rubbed out the plus with his thumb and wrote a minus in its place, and carried the work down again, and arrived at twenty-eight.
He put the chalk on the ledge and turned to face the room.
Judith had thought, in the three nights she had lain awake, of many things he might do. She had thought he might bluster; she had thought he might blame his computers; she had thought, most likely of all, that he would say something gracious and empty about the uncertainties of observation at sea, and sit down, and let the Board quietly bury the matter. She had not thought that he would look as he did look now: an old man, suddenly, standing very straight in his gown, with chalk on his thumb.
“Gentlemen,” said Sir Augustus Threlkeld. “Dr. Wray. Mr. Carrow.” His voice was quite steady. “It is quite an error.”
The room was entirely silent.
“It is my error,” he went on. “Not my computers’. I computed the third table myself, in the winter of the year six, by logarithms, at night, and I never carried the sign. I have had it in my hand eleven years and never once looked. The young lady is right in every particular. The tables are to be withdrawn from the printer this afternoon, and not issued until the third table is corrected and the whole of it examined.” He paused. “By a competent computer. I should be obliged, Dr. Wray, if the Board would recommend one to me.”