It was his aunt, Lady Prudence Beale, Lord Reginald’s sister, who finally convinced him to return, though for reasons very different from those she confessed to him. Lady Prudence had been visiting Ashcombe Hall for months with a frequency that had nothing to do with familial affection. Widowed and in debt due to her late husband’s poor investments, she had begun to insinuate, first subtly and then without pretense, that Lord Reginald’s condition worsened daily and that perhaps it was time to consider a formal certification of incapacity before the Commissioners in Lunacy, so that someone trusted—herself, of course—could manage the family estates while the duke attended to his obligations in London. She had even gone so far as to speak privately with Dr. Mead, the family physician, suggesting to him, with a generosity that did not go unnoticed, that an opinion favoring certification would be handsomely rewarded.

Dr. Mead, a man of principles though not of great fortune, had neither fully accepted nor rejected the proposal, and that indecision was exactly what Lady Prudence needed to continue maneuvering. If she succeeded in having Lord Reginald declared incapable of managing his affairs, the law would grant her, as a close relative, the right to assume responsibility and considerable control over the estate’s income until the duke himself returned permanently, something Lady Prudence knew he would avoid for as long as he could. When the duke arrived unannounced that November night, it was not because of Whitlock’s letters or his aunt’s insinuations. It was because, after months of avoiding it, he suddenly felt a shame he could no longer put off.

He walked through the front door, weary from the journey, prepared to face the same scene as always: his father confused, his mother crying, the house sunk in silent disarray. Instead, he found the dining room lit by candles, the table set with old-fashioned care, and his parents sitting side by side, hands joined over the tablecloth in grace before dinner. Lord Reginald had his head bowed and his eyes closed, at peace. Lady Honoria, in a dress that Marianne had pulled from the bottom of a trunk and pressed with care, had her hands clasped and a serene expression the duke did not remember seeing in years. And standing beside them, with her hands also joined and eyes closed in a gesture of silent respect, was a young woman he did not know, dressed simply, yet with a dignity that needed no adornment.

The candles in the silver candelabra, lit one by one by her own hand that afternoon, flickered slightly in the draft from the ajar door, and the soft rustle of her starched linen apron was, for an instant, the only sound in the entire room before Lord Reginald whispered the amen. The duke stood motionless in the doorway without anyone noticing his presence for a time that seemed much longer to him than it actually was. He watched his father smile, watched his mother breathe calmly, and felt something he could not name; it was not just relief. It was a kind of painful wonder, the sudden certainty that this stranger had achieved, with nothing more than patience and an old song, what he himself had not achieved with all his title and all his fortune.