“Marianne, there is something I must tell you.”

She looked up with the shears still in her hand, and for an instant, the air between them seemed to stand still. But before he could continue, Lady Prudence’s sharp voice rang out from the conservatory door, announcing without any apology that she had arrived for a visit and expected to be received immediately. The duke closed his eyes for a second, frustrated, and the moment dissolved like smoke. Lady Prudence, upon learning that her nephew had extended his stay at Ashcombe Hall and, above all, discovering the reason, realized her plan was in jeopardy. If the duke stayed, if he trusted that maid with no past or references, her own maneuvers with Dr. Mead and the Lunacy Commissioners would be exposed long before bearing fruit.

She decided then to act quickly. During dinner, she announced before the entire family that a pearl brooch, a legacy from her late mother, was missing, and that she had left it, she was certain, on the vanity in Lady Honoria’s room the last time she visited. No one else had seen it since. The insinuation was clear, though not spoken aloud: the only new person in the house, the only one without references to prove her honesty, was Marianne. The duke wanted to defend her immediately, but Lady Prudence, with a skill perfected through years of drawing-room intrigue, insisted that justice must take its course without favoritism and that allowing a mere maid to remain in the house while under such grave suspicion would be a lack of responsibility toward his own parents.

Whitlock, uncomfortable, was forced to search Marianne’s belongings in front of the other servants, a humiliating process that produced no brooch but did not leave her reputation intact either, because suspicion, once sown, needs no proof to grow. The duke, torn between his duty to his aunt and what his heart already knew with certainty, made the mistake of remaining silent for a whole day while he tried to decide what to do. That silence was enough for Lady Prudence, taking advantage of his absence at a meeting with the tenants, to convince Dr. Mead to sign a preliminary opinion on Lord Reginald’s state, alleging that the recent turmoil in the house, caused, according to her, by the theft scandal, had dangerously aggravated his condition. With that document in hand, she formally requested that Marianne be dismissed immediately as a precaution while the brooch matter was being resolved.

Marianne was dismissed that very afternoon without a chance to say goodbye to Lady Honoria, who wept, not understanding why the young girl from the song no longer sat by her window. She walked back toward the village under a cold drizzle, carrying the same frayed bundle she had arrived with, thinking that, after all, fate had returned her to the very place she had tried to escape. But she never reached the doors of the asylum. The village reverend, who knew her from the few services she had managed to attend, offered her a corner in the sacristy for the night, and it was there, warming her hands by a candle, that Marianne decided she would not leave without telling the truth, even if no one believed her.