Meanwhile, at Ashcombe Hall, Lord Reginald had worsened significantly since Marianne’s departure. Without the melody that calmed him at night, his screams returned louder than before, and Lady Honoria, not seeing the young woman who brushed her hair each evening, fell into a silence that worried even the most senior servants. The duke, seeing his parents lose in just two days everything they had gained in a month, began to suspect that something about the brooch story did not add up and that his aunt was too eager for the young woman to leave right at that moment. It was then that Lady Honoria herself, in one of those moments of lucidity that sometimes pierced her clouded memory like a ray of sunlight, took her son’s hand during dinner and asked him, with a clarity she hadn’t possessed in months, where the girl who sang was.

The duke, moved to his core by that simple and devastating question, decided not to wait another day. He went himself, against all protocol, to the village sacristy to speak with Marianne, and it was she, with her usual serene honesty, who told him exactly what had happened: that she had never touched the brooch, that she hadn’t even known it existed until the night its disappearance was announced, and that she had no defense but her own word, because a maid without references never has anything more than that. The duke believed her, not because he had proof, but because in a month he had learned to distinguish between the silence of guilt and the silence of wounded dignity. Together they returned to Ashcombe Hall that same night, and the duke, without announcing his intentions to anyone, ordered the entire house to be searched again, this time with greater care, starting with his own aunt’s chambers.

The pearl brooch was found at the back of a locked drawer in Lady Prudence’s room, wrapped in a handkerchief alongside several letters to Dr. Mead that openly discussed the terms of a reward in exchange for his signature. The confrontation that followed was brief, because Lady Prudence, once discovered, did not even try to deny the obvious, but instead appealed, with tears that convinced no one, to the loyalty of blood and the hardships of her own widowhood. The duke, with a coldness that surprised everyone present, told her that her widowhood would be provided for with a modest pension, but she would never again set foot in Ashcombe Hall or go near his parents. Dr. Mead, ashamed, retracted his preliminary opinion in writing and confirmed, with total honesty this time, that both Lord Reginald and Lady Honoria, while suffering from an age-related condition that clouded their memory, retained full awareness of affection and will, and that no certification of incapacity was justified.