There was a small house at Matlock, and she was to have that for her life, with enough to live on. He handed her into the carriage himself that evening, and stood on the steps until it was out of sight. The magistrate had, in the meantime, taken up the paper with the charge on it. He looked at it for a while, then across at the thin young woman in the darned gloves. Then he tore it in two.
“I have sat on that bench for 20 years,” he said in a carrying voice, “and I never saw a hand better proved. I should like that to be heard. As for keepers, I have just heard a man recite 11 years of letters with his eyes shut, and I would like to meet the physician, who will call him an idiot.”
An old farmer from the high ground, cleared his throat, and turned his hat around. He wanted to know, begging His Grace’s pardon, who was to read for the Dale from now on, and who for His Grace. And it was the strangest thing, for nobody said a word. But one by one the faces turned, the same that had turned that morning. The Duke asked it of them formally, as a thing to be decided, and every hand in that hall went up.
Charlotte’s went up last of all. She held it there and did not look away. It was nearly dark when Cecilia found him on the top step with the mist coming up through the yews. She sat down beside him on the cold stone where the grass grew in the joints. For a while neither spoke.
“I want to say something aloud,” she said. “I read a great many letters today. I could have read every one of them from now until Christmas, and they would have gone on believing what they believed. They believed it because of what it cost you. Nobody else alive could have stood on that floor. Nobody else had those 11 years in his head. You did the one thing that I could never have done for you, and I wanted you to hear me say so.”
He said nothing for a moment. She saw the corner of his mouth move.
“You turned the page around,” he said.
He took her hand and held it against his knee. They sat there until Josiah came out, coughed, and mentioned that the tea was getting cold. Then, for almost a fortnight, she did not see him. There was plenty to do. Her uncle came down the dale with his hat in his hands and stood in Mrs. Wildgoose’s kitchen, and her aunt sent a ham, which was as near as her aunt could come to it.
She read out the good news in house after house, and the geese went by on the road, and the first true cold came down from the moor. She told herself that a man who has broken open his life must need time to look at the pieces. She was a practical person. She slept very badly. On a gray afternoon in the middle of October, a very old man came slowly down the road with a flat packet under his arm.
Josiah would not sit. He laid it on the table among the blue plates. She looked at the string around it and stopped with her hand in the air. She knew that knot. She had been undoing that knot on the dairy sill every quarter day for four years.
“That was you,” she said.
“I carried it, miss,” said Josiah. “He bought it. It was the Monday he had to go through Bakewell four years ago last spring with the blinds down, and he had me stop the carriage at the bottom of the street, well back from the cross. There was an old soldier on your crate with his sleeve pinned up. You’d got a letter for him, and you were reading it with your head bent close so that nobody else should hear. Then you put the pen in his hand to make his mark, and you looked away while he did it. His Grace watched until the old man had gone. He sent me to ask your name at the egg stall, and when you had packed up and gone, he had me bring him a daisy from the foot of the cross. I never knew why. He kept it in the Virgil.”